View Full Version : Melbourne's smartcard winning bidder announced


tayser
July 12th, 2005, 05:47 AM
http://www.theage.com.au/news/national/us-bidder-wins-500m-ticketing-contract/2005/07/12/1120934223813.html

US bidder wins $500m ticketing contract
By Dan Silkstone
Transport reporter
July 12, 2005 - 1:21PM

Related

* Ticketing: How it will work (http://www.theage.com.au/news/national/how-it-will-work/2005/07/12/1120934225520.html)

The State Government has announced the winning bidder for the $494 million contract to supply the state's new public transport smart card.

American company Keane Incorporated was announced this morning to build, install and run the new system, which will begin operating in 2007.

Premier Steve Bracks said the system would create 100 jobs, but the biggest winners would be the state's commuters.

"The ticket they use to catch a train from Bendigo will be the same as the ticket they use to catch a tram to St Kilda," he said.

Mr Bracks said commuters would not need to know what zone they were in when they bought a ticket, what zones they were travelling through or what the cheapest available fare would be.

The card automatically recognises the user's position in the transport network and the cheapest available fare.

The founder and chairman of Keane, John F Keane, said he was delighted to be the winning bidder.

"We are 100 per cent committed to the success of this program . . . and committed to making this the benchmark to which other ticketing systems compare themselves," Mr Keane said.

Keane, an IT and business services firm, is the major partner in a consortium known as KAMCO.

The consortium also includes ASCOM, which will provide fare-collection equipment; Perth company ERG, which will be responsible for installation and maintenance; and Melbourne firm GND, which will provide the cards.

ERG was a surprise latecomer to the bid. The firm was behind the introduction of the current metcard in 1997 and had put in a separate bid for the smartcard contract, which was eliminated earlier in the tender process.

Keane operates in the US, Canada, India and the UK.

The company's other transport clients include CSX Technology, a Fortune 500 company, and Railinc.

The State Opposition had earlier raised concerns about the tender process.

FOI documents revealed that Victoria's Transport Ticketing Authority paid Keane $230,000 for a three-month consultancy last year on an "open-architecture" system, which would avoid the need for the Government to be locked into a contract linked to specific hardware.

The Liberal Party says on its website that two consultants worked in Melbourne for as much as $15,000 a week.

But the authority's general manager, Duncan Bryce, said the open-architecture requirement was only a small part of the tender process, and that Keane had been asked to provide advice because there were a limited number of experts in the field.

Melbourne is the first Australian city to opt for a such a system, although it is becoming popular overseas. Sydney, Brisbane and Perth have recently decided to adopt systems that do not feature open architecture.

Some industry sources say the focus upon open architecture could have given the American company a competitive advantage because it is expert in such systems and, unlike some of the other bidders, is not a developer of ticketing hardware.

More than 71 million metcards were sold in Melbourne last year.

- theage.com.au

zachary24
July 13th, 2005, 03:29 PM
finally melbourne has done what sydney, perth, and south-east queensland has done - however with a lower quality technology than Cubic or ERG - which are clearly leaders in this field! never mind at least u guys still getting a system

zachary24
July 13th, 2005, 03:47 PM
well erg is part of winning bid - however their technology will not be used - damn shame

NailZ
July 14th, 2005, 04:12 AM
Hi Guys,

I work for ERG, I was VERY dissapointed a couple of months ago when we were knocked out of the tender process. This is a good result for us, since the maintenance and installation contracts in the past have been lucrative.

Still, its a shame. Would have liked to be seconded to work in Melbounre :)

perthguy78
July 14th, 2005, 03:36 PM
why has melb waited so long for this?? Perth and Bris are already in trials

Drunkill
July 14th, 2005, 03:57 PM
Blame Jeff Kennet...

cammo2004
July 17th, 2005, 12:03 PM
why has melb waited so long for this?? Perth and Bris are already in trials

And Sydney. Yes, Even we're in trials (albeit only on buses atm but still...)

tayser
July 17th, 2005, 12:30 PM
because we're letting the knots get ironed out by you lot before a full scale installation is attempted ;) we learnt that lesson with Metcard.

perthguy78
July 17th, 2005, 04:02 PM
can't you learn from the hundreds of similar sized cities around the world who have rolled out transit cards :D hehe

Daffy
July 18th, 2005, 03:17 AM
It's interesting to note that the system just for collection fares is going to cost $500m. It seems a lot of money to spend on something that is only going to generate something like $210m per year (71m annual metcards by average of about $3 per ticket).

Jimmy James
August 14th, 2005, 05:31 AM
Mr Bracks said commuters would not need to know what zone they were in when they bought a ticket, what zones they were travelling through or what the cheapest available fare would be.

The card automatically recognises the user's position in the transport network and the cheapest available fare.

- theage.com.au

Sure it will - just like the way my power and phone bills are 100% correct every time huh!

invincible
August 14th, 2005, 01:20 PM
It's just as bad when you live on the edge of two zones - often there's bus drivers that don't know where the overlap ends, which is really annoying since most of my travel is in Zone 2 but a couple of blocks down and I have to pretty much pay double for the extra distance.

But somehow I'd have a bit more faith in this system, but I'm sure people will still be "accidentally" tagging off. :)