View Full Version : Workers Riot at Site of Burj Dubai


AltiusAltiusAltius
March 23rd, 2006, 09:39 AM
Workers Riot at Site of Dubai Skyscraper By JIM KRANE, Associated Press Writer
Wed Mar 22, 2:07 PM ET



DUBAI, United Arab Emirates - Asian workers angered by low salaries and mistreatment smashed cars and offices in a riot that interrupted construction Wednesday of what is meant to be the world's tallest skyscraper — including a luxury hotel run by Giorgio Armani.

The violence, which caused an estimated $1 million damage, illustrated the growing unrest among foreign workers who are the linchpin of Dubai's breathtaking building boom.

Some 2,500 workers on the Burj Dubai tower and surrounding housing developments chased and beat security officers Tuesday night, then broke into offices where they smashed computers and files, witnesses said. They said about two dozen cars and construction machines were wrecked.

When the laborers, who work for the Dubai-based firm Al Naboodah Laing O'Rourke, returned to the vast construction site Wednesday, they demanded better pay and employment conditions and refused to return to work. In a sympathy strike, thousands of laborers building a terminal at Dubai International Airport also lay down their tools.

"Everyone is angry here. No one will work," said Khalid Farouk, 39, a laborer with Al Naboodah. Others said their leaders were asking for pay raises: skilled carpenters on the site earn $7.60 per day, with laborers getting $4 per day.

The riot was a rare outbreak of violence, but it was not the first sign of discontent among the foreigners who form the overwhelming majority of private sector workers in most oil-rich Gulf countries. There have been strikes in recent months in Qatar and Oman. In April, Bangladeshis stormed their own embassy in Kuwait, protesting working conditions that human rights activists have denounced as "slave-like."

Millions of foreign workers have flooded Gulf nations, outweighing the population of citizens in Kuwait, the United Arab Emirates and Qatar. In Saudi Arabia, foreign workers make up about 21 percent of the population of more than 26 million, but labor unrest is rare in the tightly controlled country.

The foreigners are professionals like doctors, scientists, businessmen and oil workers; skilled laborers such as electricians; or do unskilled jobs in restaurants or homes. Human rights groups have often decried abuse of low-paid foreign workers by their employers — particularly of women in domestic labor.

In the Emirates, where some estimates say more than three-quarters of the population of around 5 million people are foreigners, migrants from India, Pakistan, Bangladesh, China and elsewhere have provided the low-wage muscle behind one of the world's great building booms.

Dubai, one of seven emirates making up the country, hosts some 300,000 South Asians working in the construction field alone, helping propel it from a primitive town of 20,000 five decades ago to a gridlocked metropolis of 1.5 million — only 12 percent of whom are citizens.

But workers complain their employers often withhold pay. They enjoy few legal protections and no minimum wage, work in the extreme heat, and many of them live in military-style desert camps.

Angry workers in the Emirates held more than two dozen strikes over unpaid salaries last year, mainly in Dubai. The Labor Ministry responded with a crackdown on companies, helping win back pay and other benefits for some workers.

Labor officials said companies that breach contracts embarrass the image-conscious Emirates by attracting condemnation from the United Nations, the United States and Human Rights Watch.

On Wednesday, crowds of blue-garbed workers milled in the shadow of the gray concrete Burj Dubai, now 36 stories tall, while leaders negotiated with officials from the company and the Ministry of Labor.

An Interior Ministry official who investigates labor issues, Lt. Col. Rashid Bakhit Al Jumairi, said the workers were petitioning Al Naboodah, one of the Emirates' biggest construction conglomerates, for overtime pay, better medical care and humane treatment by foremen.

"They are asking for small things," Al Jumairi said. "I promised them I would sit with them until everything is settled."

Later Wednesday, a spokesman for Al Naboodah Laing O'Rourke — a joint venture with the conglomerate — blamed the violence on "misinformation and misunderstanding with some of our work force."

The spokesman, Mark Way, said in a statement that the "issues have now been addressed and resolved" and the workers were resuming their jobs. He gave no details on how the workers' complaints were addressed, and workers' representatives could not be immediately reached for comment.

The unrest marred what otherwise appears to be smooth construction of the Burj Dubai, which is to be a spire-shaped, stainless-steel-skinned tower expected to soar far beyond 100 stories. A section of the tower is to host a 172-room luxury hotel operated by Armani, the Italian fashion designer. The $900 million Burj is due to be completed by 2008.

___

thunder head
March 23rd, 2006, 12:45 PM
$4 per day. Dubai is sucking th life out of these workers. Hell, they have every right to be pissed off.

Grollo
March 23rd, 2006, 12:58 PM
I don't blame them.

Favco750
March 23rd, 2006, 01:26 PM
stick it to the bastards brothers!!!!!

CULWULLA
March 23rd, 2006, 01:34 PM
emaar are such arseholes. the workers deserve so much more.hope there looked after.

KJBrissy
March 23rd, 2006, 01:47 PM
Sounds like the USA to me!!!!

Locke
March 23rd, 2006, 02:56 PM
They got it tough, but compared to what they'd get in India, it's still worth going over for them. They save up in Dubai a bit they can usually go back to India or Pakistan after a few years and be a lot better off.

Dilaz89
March 23rd, 2006, 03:59 PM
I hope good old Kev reads that article.
Fat lazy prick!

yeah they have every right to be pissed off.Espeacislly since they are making so much money from it.

But i suppose this is why we dont have megascrapers in Aus.

Tall buildings come at a price.

Citystyle
March 23rd, 2006, 07:25 PM
Progress occurs as positive and as negative for dubai the cheap labour is, it will change. When i dont know.

FREKI
March 23rd, 2006, 07:43 PM
$4 per day. Dubai is sucking the life out of these workers. Hell, they have every right to be pissed off.

I agree - It's sick!


$4/day is nothing, I make more in 11 minutes! It's practicly slave labour! :sleepy:

nomarandlee2
March 23rd, 2006, 09:44 PM
Sounds like the USA to me!!!!


are you on crack son? Do you know what an insult that is? 4 dollars a day vs. 100-250 dollars a day (probaby much more in many cases)?

Not to mention they are allow to form unions and get paid overtime in the U.S.

That comparison is sickening. Go back to school.

nomarandlee2
March 23rd, 2006, 09:47 PM
They got it tough, but compared to what they'd get in India, it's still worth going over for them. They save up in Dubai a bit they can usually go back to India or Pakistan after a few years and be a lot better off.

At best what are they making 1,000-1,500 dollars a year at those wages? That is not much higher then the Indian per capita. I would hardly say they save and it allows them to go live it up back home when they return.

MILIUX
March 24th, 2006, 03:36 AM
Here's the perfect formula to build Towers in Dubai

Cheap labour + cheap land (desert) + cheap credits = Construction. So this is how they make it economically viable?

Be proud of Australia's construction and development. We don't exploit labour like the fucking UAE.

MelbourneCity
March 24th, 2006, 04:36 AM
I suppose the cheap labour explains why Dubai has become so rich so quickly - other than oil.
I don't blame them for rioting. Working $4 a day? No way we would allow it in this country.
They would not have an easy job either - hot & dangerous.

thunder head
March 24th, 2006, 05:06 AM
Let's deport that retard Captain Chaos to work as a slave in Dubai.

Locke
March 24th, 2006, 05:50 AM
At best what are they making 1,000-1,500 dollars a year at those wages? That is not much higher then the Indian per capita. I would hardly say they save and it allows them to go live it up back home when they return.

I wouldn't go off statistics for this, if you are over in Dubai you are probably reasonably poor and uneducated, and it allows you to make a good living compared to what you could do in India, where you could likely end up on the street.

They still earn significantly more than back home, if they didn't I guarantee you none of them would be their sweating it out away from their families if they didn't think it was worth there while. Whilst some work hard I've also seen plenty others who do not.

Dudes on constructions sites and roadworks have it the hardest because of the heat, but if you work in an office or admin role, or if you are a maid, then conditions can be very good compared to back home.

Usually, they buy food etc in groups and spend next to nothing whilst they are there, and I mean nothing. So they can save.

Then when they leave to go back home you seem em at the airport with their giant cheap indian duty free tv's that they are lugging back to India, always in breach of all their luggage allowance.

So it's hard work, but it sure beats being out on the street in India or Sri Lanka. It's all relative.

dukkie69
April 3rd, 2006, 07:32 AM
maybe the wage its not that low. every country is different, the wage will have to go accordin to wat u need to spend in that country, u cannot always change the money back into US$... wat if in dubai the food is so cheap, lets say $1 is already enough... same thing with japan, people always complain that japan is expensive... but then japanese get paid high (if u convert to dollars), thats why stuffs are not expensive to them, and its just normal... so maybe 4$ in dubai is already a lot for the locals. im not 100% sure how much the average local person spend in dubai a day, but im just sayin, it might not be as bad as u guys think.

Citystyle
April 3rd, 2006, 10:29 AM
Dubai is expensive but they share living costs.

RADULA
April 3rd, 2006, 12:20 PM
Dubai is a very cheap place to live currently, for example food, no taxes, ridiculously priced cars and fuel. You can buy a pack of smokes for less than 2 australian dollars (here its more like $11).
Unfortunately what we are starting to see now is that the construction boom is attracting more wealth into the area, as a result dubai is becoming a more expensive place to live, while pay rates are remaining low. Unless they do something about this then its just a recipe for economic troubles in the future.

If the arabs want to build their own international hub, they need to make sure their workers are nor exploited they way they are. For people who come from countries like india and bangladesh to complain about workers rights, thats saying something! One thing I found when I was over there myself recently, is that the emirate nationals don't have much respect for foreign cultures. Indians and pakistanis in particular have far less rights and protection than higher respected and oil rich muslims (emirate nationals and saudi's), I personally feel that dubai is going to struggle when there is no more oil left (which will probably be in the next 10 years or so).

elfreako
April 3rd, 2006, 05:02 PM
I read somewhere that oil only contributes 7% of Dubai's economy. I'm pretty sure we'll be seeing many more Indians being screwed by exploitative contractors for years to come. I long for the day when oil-less Gulf Arabs are forced to work menial toilet-cleaning duties in Mumbai. Given the growth of India's economy, this day is hopefully not too far off! :lol:

SA BOY
April 4th, 2006, 01:52 PM
I doubt it mate, thats why they are investing heavily in off shore diversified investements. The Arabs are the biggest single investors in the states with the Saudis practically owning corporate america.

SA BOY
April 4th, 2006, 01:56 PM
depending on what you read there is between 30-100 years left of oil here so I will be long retired when the shit hits the fan, between now and then oil will continue to rise up to $100 a barrel and above towards the end , no matter how much they pump.
as for the net wiorth of lives in Dubai, we have something here called blood money which is payable to the family if aomeone is killed and there is a guilty party ie run someone over you pay. if you kill a UAE national it will cost you AED 200 000 , kill a western expat and it will cost AED 100 000 and if you kill a asian (indian, pakistani, nepaleese , bangladeshi or sri lankan ) it will cost you only AED 50 000.
Thats the way it is , end of story, no debate

Wezza
April 4th, 2006, 02:29 PM
Dubai is a very cheap place to live currently, for example food, no taxes, ridiculously priced cars and fuel. You can buy a pack of smokes for less than 2 australian dollars (here its more like $11).
Unfortunately what we are starting to see now is that the construction boom is attracting more wealth into the area, as a result dubai is becoming a more expensive place to live, while pay rates are remaining low. Unless they do something about this then its just a recipe for economic troubles in the future.
So roughly $2 for cigarettes, thats still half of someones daily pay..........

luv2bebrown
April 4th, 2006, 09:34 PM
rent and school fees can be very expensive

LA53R
April 5th, 2006, 03:18 AM
Not a good idea pissing off the people who are BUILDING this tower, haha they might dodgy it up so it falls over, i mean they have no problem rioting and smashing equipment.
Would you care about your work for $4 a day? NO i wouldn't and infact i would fuck up every chance i get like who cares if the concrete is stuffed :P

I will laugh if the Burj Dubai becomes condemned shortly after completetion because its discovered to be unsafe!

RADULA
April 6th, 2006, 12:33 PM
depending on what you read there is between 30-100 years left of oil here so I will be long retired when the shit hits the fan, between now and then oil will continue to rise up to $100 a barrel and above towards the end , no matter how much they pump.
as for the net wiorth of lives in Dubai, we have something here called blood money which is payable to the family if aomeone is killed and there is a guilty party ie run someone over you pay. if you kill a UAE national it will cost you AED 200 000 , kill a western expat and it will cost AED 100 000 and if you kill a asian (indian, pakistani, nepaleese , bangladeshi or sri lankan ) it will cost you only AED 50 000.
Thats the way it is , end of story, no debate

Also I was told that if a UAE national runs into you, they usaully either speed off or call someone to pick them up and escape the scene, so that the blame rests on the other driver. Thats why they're always drivin like maniacs on the highways, in their country they can do whatever they like. Basically if they crash into you because of their own fault and get killed, and your a westerner/ex-pat, it would probably be a good idea to get out of the country asap!

LA53R
April 7th, 2006, 04:03 AM
What the........
HAHAHA i'd make sure his car isn't running anymore take some phots of the crash and the fellow and not let him escape if someone comes to get him :)

luv2bebrown
April 7th, 2006, 10:00 AM
Also I was told that if a UAE national runs into you, they usaully either speed off or call someone to pick them up and escape the scene, so that the blame rests on the other driver. Thats why they're always drivin like maniacs on the highways, in their country they can do whatever they like. Basically if they crash into you because of their own fault and get killed, and your a westerner/ex-pat, it would probably be a good idea to get out of the country asap!

complete exaggeration. it can happen tho.
on a dubai forum on some site, i read an entry by this one dude. he claimed he had gotten into an accident with a local, and when the police came they blamed him for the accident even though it was not his fault. he took the issue to the courts and eventually the judge ruled in favor of him. the local was held responsible for the accident, and the two cops who issued the accident report in favour of the local were discharged from the police.

AltinD
April 10th, 2006, 08:07 PM
Not a good idea pissing off the people who are BUILDING this tower, haha they might dodgy it up so it falls over, i mean they have no problem rioting and smashing equipment.
Would you care about your work for $4 a day? NO i wouldn't and infact i would fuck up every chance i get like who cares if the concrete is stuffed :P

I will laugh if the Burj Dubai becomes condemned shortly after completetion because its discovered to be unsafe!

The people who rioted are NOT "...the people who are BUILDING this tower..."

They are building the Dubai Mall not to mention that the protest was about overtime and living condition, and NOT about the basic salary they have agreed upon, before comming to Dubai.

BTW the quoted $4/- per day is WRONG!

Pish-REZ-pash
April 12th, 2006, 01:12 AM
I'd agree with AltinD, there's NO WAY they'd get $4 a day for building such a huge structure.

Besdies they aren't that stupid to agree working on a $4/hour basis. They could have earned the same amount staying back home in India

Andrewwise
April 12th, 2006, 01:20 AM
and if you kill a asian (indian, pakistani, nepaleese , bangladeshi or sri lankan ) it will cost you only AED 50 000.

WTH? Isn't that a little racist?

luv2bebrown
April 13th, 2006, 07:12 AM
WTH? Isn't that a little racist?

the statement you are referring to is not true.