View Full Version : Enlargement of Schengen
ChrisZwolle July 30th, 2007, 07:30 PM Good news! All border crossings in Eastern European countries will be removed by December 2007!
EU to lift border checks as "Christmas gift" to new members
(BUDAPEST) - The European Union will in December lift border controls for citizens of nine countries which joined the bloc in 2004, a top official said Monday, adding that the move was a "Christmas present."
"We can confirm our original plans to lift land borders and maritime borders by December of this year and airport borders by March 2008," Justice Commissioner Franco Frattini told a press conference also addressed by Hungarian Prime Minister Ferenc Gyurcsany.
"We would expect to lift borders between mid-December and the end of December in the Christmas time, as a Christmas gift to all the citizens of Europe," Frattini said.
He said a formal political decision on admitting the Czech Republic, Estonia, Hungary, Latvia, Lithuania, Malta, Poland, Slovakia and Slovenia into the Schengen free-movement zone would be taken in November.
The Schengen treaty, which abolished border checks between its members, counts 15 participating countries: all the oldest EU members except Britain and Ireland, plus non-EU nations Norway and Iceland.
:cheers:
mgk920 July 30th, 2007, 08:50 PM I wish that they could do something like that here in North America. I'm still amazed that many of the countries in the Schengen zone have fought truly VICIOUS wars against each other more than once within the past 100 years, while the USA and Mexico have been at peace for 100 years or so and the USA and Canada haven't fired a shot in anger at each other since the end of the War of 1812 - and yet the checkpoints in North America are getting harder and harder to cross on a nearly daily basis.
:ohno: :ohno: :ohno: :ohno:
As it is now, though, I do see a lot of similarities between the Schengen zone and the USA itself, when you think of the individual USA states as being country-like semi-sovereign entities that all use a common currency and a common external border.
Mike
Rebasepoiss July 30th, 2007, 09:38 PM So....does this mean that I don't have to show my ID-card when I'm going to Finland, for example??? :) ...This is great! I knew that it will happen some day but not so soon. I thought of something like in the middle of 2008.
(I can drive to Portugal without stopping, wooohhooo! :D)
ChrisZwolle July 30th, 2007, 09:41 PM If you drive to Germany, you can pass Latvia, Lithuania and Poland, all without stopping at the borders :) Saves you at least a couple of hours.
I think it might be a boost for tourism too. People here are so used to open borders, they are afraid for hours of waiting for the border, so they rather drive 1600km to Barcelona, than 800km to Praha.
mgk920 July 30th, 2007, 09:45 PM So....does this mean that I don't have to show my ID-card when I'm going to Finland, for example??? :) ...This is great! I knew that it will happen some day but not so soon. I thought of something like in the middle of 2008.
Yes. Taking the ferry between Tallinn and Helsinki will be like crossing between two states (such as taking a ferry across Lake Michigan between Manitowoc, WI and Ludington, MI) here in the USA.
The Euro will make that crossing even easier, too.
Mike
Rebasepoiss July 30th, 2007, 11:11 PM ^Yeah, but Estonia won't get EURO before 2012.
edolen1 July 31st, 2007, 03:17 AM Yaay, we'll be fully integrated just in time for the Presidency! :happy:
Anyways, this has been known for a couple of months now, but good thing the word is spreading, means it's happening for sure..
By the way, Slovenia already installed the SIS on our systems so we are tehnically and formally ready to join Schengen. Yaaaaay!
Xusein July 31st, 2007, 05:52 AM I wish that they could do something like that here in North America. I'm still amazed that many of the countries in the Schengen zone have fought truly VICIOUS wars against each other more than once within the past 100 years, while the USA and Mexico have been at peace for 100 years or so and the USA and Canada haven't fired a shot in anger at each other since the end of the War of 1812 - and yet the checkpoints in North America are getting harder and harder to cross on a nearly daily basis.
Absolutely...makes me all the more jealous when I hear about Schengen. :(
Maxx☢Power July 31st, 2007, 12:02 PM That's great news :)
ChrisZwolle July 31st, 2007, 04:33 PM Absolutely...makes me all the more jealous when I hear about Schengen. :(
Yeah, but you have to cross only one border to acces a large portion of Northern America.
For Europeans, if they wanna go to Hungary or Croatia, they have to cross like 4 borders within 1000km/600 miles.
edolen1 July 31st, 2007, 10:37 PM ^^Well, Croatia will still remain a problem, but at least loads of other countries won't..
De Vorst August 1st, 2007, 03:50 PM Schengen map
http://www.susy07.uni-karlsruhe.de/graphics/SchengenKarte.gif
fredru$ August 1st, 2007, 04:46 PM How'bout Switzerland?
.
keber August 1st, 2007, 05:18 PM Not in this turn. Switzerland is considering to join Schengen, but they won't join now. Above map is wrong.
This one is better. Dark blue already in Schengen, middle blue joining Schengen, light blue going to Schengen in some years.
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/0/09/SchengenAgreement_map.png
Jonesy55 August 1st, 2007, 05:22 PM Hopefully the UK and Ireland will join one day but I don't think it would make much difference to us, you would still have to stop at the border to get onto a ferry/train or you will drive into the sea.
Our only land border between Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland is already completely open anyway.
mgk920 August 1st, 2007, 05:43 PM Hopefully the UK and Ireland will join one day but I don't think it would make much difference to us, you would still have to stop at the border to get onto a ferry/train or you will drive into the sea.
Our only land border between Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland is already completely open anyway.
Aren't the UK/Ireland's inspections mainly to keep 'invasive' plant/animal/disease species off of the islands?
Mike
GENIUS LOCI August 1st, 2007, 05:53 PM Hopefully the UK and Ireland will join one day but I don't think it would make much difference to us, you would still have to stop at the border to get onto a ferry/train or you will drive into the sea.
The difference will be over all about 'commercial' limitation: Schengen will make 'em fall down
Mattboy August 2nd, 2007, 01:38 AM Not in this turn. Switzerland is considering to join Schengen, but they won't join now. Above map is wrong.
This one is better. Dark blue already in Schengen, middle blue joining Schengen, light blue going to Schengen in some years.
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/0/09/SchengenAgreement_map.png
Not exactly so. All the blue-coloured countries are already signatoires of the Schengen Agreement. Dark blue means they have already implemented it. Then those who are implementing it in december. Light-blue countries are members implementing it later (Switzerland aims to do so in November 2008, Romania and Bulgaria in 2011 and Cyprus is uncertain).
Yellow countries (Liechtenstein and Vatican City) have expressed interest in joining. And green (Monaco) means not official membership, but de facto.
Every country joining the EU in the future is joining Schengen at the same time (Bulgaria and Romania became members of both institutions on 1 January 2007)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schengen_agreement
Xusein August 2nd, 2007, 07:54 AM Yeah, but you have to cross only one border to acces a large portion of Northern America.
Yeah, but it's slowly closing by the minute.
Europe and North America are moving in opposite directions.
ChrisZwolle August 2nd, 2007, 02:25 PM How'bout Switzerland?
.
Most times i passed the Swiss border, they just wave you through, usually there isn't even a passport check or something.
Gatis August 2nd, 2007, 04:38 PM If somebody would say this to me in 1988 - I would not believe. Then going to Moon seemed a lot simpler than going to Sweden.
Can tell some stories, f.e. in our school (I ended in 1988) one guy was excellent in German language, he won competition and was recognised as the best in Latvia in his age. As a present he got a permit to go and visit Eastern Germany. Everybody envyed him very much. But... the visit to Eastern Germany coincided with exams in Academy of Arts where he wanted to study. And in these times - if you did not enter the highschool after completion of school, you were drawn in Soviet Army with high chances to die in Afghanistan or just from beating of fellow "comrades".
Without much thinking he decided to go to Eastern Germany - he missed his highschool and had to spend 2 years in humiliating conditions in Soviet Army for this. But he was happy about his decision then.
Such luxury as visit to Western Germany was beyond the wildest dreams.
DJZG August 3rd, 2007, 09:08 AM Not in this turn. Switzerland is considering to join Schengen, but they won't join now. Above map is wrong.
This one is better. Dark blue already in Schengen, middle blue joining Schengen, light blue going to Schengen in some years.
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/0/09/SchengenAgreement_map.png
looking at the map and living in Croatia... damn... this is so isolating... last 10 years we could go to Slovenia or Hungary just with identification card, now we need to show passport... really frustrating...:ohno:
Maxx☢Power August 3rd, 2007, 08:21 PM Aren't the UK/Ireland's inspections mainly to keep 'invasive' plant/animal/disease species off of the islands?
Mike
And invasive people, according to some ;)
Ireland didn't join Schengen basically because that would mean they'd have to quit the Common Travel Area which would mean they'd have to show their IDs to go to Northern Ireland and the rest of the UK.
Sławek August 3rd, 2007, 11:43 PM looking at the map and living in Croatia... damn... this is so isolating... last 10 years we could go to Slovenia or Hungary just with identification card, now we need to show passport... really frustrating...:ohno:
It's look like that Croatia is very near EU integration :)
igorlan August 3rd, 2007, 11:49 PM It's look like that Croatia is very near EU integration :)
Most certainly deserves to be within the structure, but won't join until 2010 or better I guess.
DJZG August 4th, 2007, 12:14 AM Most certainly deserves to be within the structure, but won't join until 2010 or better I guess.
well if we talk about schengen it's going to happen when and important IF we enter EU... polls say that 50% of citizens are against joining, we're just sceptical about all that...hehe.. we're learning from a history of 900 years under other states :D
but geographicaly looking, our roads are top class, highways are constructing everyday, tourism boost is one of the largest in europe i'll say, even though we could enter EU, we could also stay something like Switzerland :D but with sea :P
igorlan August 4th, 2007, 12:37 AM we could also stay something like Switzerland :D but with sea :P
Come on mate, face it, you won't afford to stay outside, this is first of all within your interest to become a part of UE, even Switzerland will join Schengen in a couple of years not to mention that they might be a part of EU sooner or later.
Rebasepoiss August 4th, 2007, 10:35 PM ^Why would Switzerland want to become a part of EU? Switzerland is better off without it.
DiggerD21 August 4th, 2007, 11:09 PM Switzerland wouldn't give up their centuries-old political neutrality and sovereignty tradition so easily, which would automatically happen if they join the EU.
sk August 5th, 2007, 11:38 PM cyprus will join schengen when our 2 new airports are finished(end of 2009). the goverment does not want to waste money to upgrade security checking in the current airports.
our sea ports are almost 100% ready.
the other problem with implementing schengen in cyprus is that we will have to increase control at the green line dividing the island,which our goverment does not want to do it as it will increase the feeling of 2 states on the island .
cyprus is having talks with brussels trying to find a solution to this problem
Vrachar August 6th, 2007, 10:22 AM looking at the map and living in Croatia... damn... this is so isolating... last 10 years we could go to Slovenia or Hungary just with identification card, now we need to show passport... really frustrating...:ohno:
Sure, it's very frustrating. :| What would you say if you need not just passport but visa also, like rest of Western Balkanas. :ohno:
igorlan August 6th, 2007, 10:39 AM Sure, it's very frustrating. :| What would you say if you need not just passport but visa also, like rest of Western Balkanas. :ohno:
You guys still need visas to enter EU??????
Vrachar August 6th, 2007, 12:26 PM ^^
Yes, unfortunately. :ohno:
I've just got Schengen visa for my trip to Portugal in next week. To get the visa I had to provide tons of documents. It costed me lot of time, nerves and money. Just to have opportunity to go there and spend my hard earned money.
Jonesy55 August 6th, 2007, 12:56 PM The difference will be over all about 'commercial' limitation: Schengen will make 'em fall down
Would Schengen really make that much of a difference to commercial barriers? There is a single European market regardless of Schengen, I don't think that a requirement to show a passport would really block much trade.
Maybe if some countries were previously very strict with controls and large queues formed at the borders this would be a problem but here at least the customs controls are usually very quick, the customs officers just wave most people through without stopping them.
ChrisZwolle August 6th, 2007, 04:22 PM ^^ You forget the hours of waiting time for trucks (commercial traffic) at the borders. Now the time is reduced since Poland belongs to EU, but a few years ago, you easily could wait one day at the border if you were a truck driver.
igorlan August 6th, 2007, 05:35 PM ^^ You forget the hours of waiting time for trucks (commercial traffic) at the borders. Now the time is reduced since Poland belongs to EU, but a few years ago, you easily could wait one day at the border if you were a truck driver.
Just literally yesterday, it was on Polish news channel (TVN24) that there was some major server outage on Ukrainian border which caused a huge queue of trucks as a result. The estimated queue time was roughly 12 hours.
AUchamps August 7th, 2007, 06:19 AM If somebody would say this to me in 1988 - I would not believe. Then going to Moon seemed a lot simpler than going to Sweden.
Can tell some stories, f.e. in our school (I ended in 1988) one guy was excellent in German language, he won competition and was recognised as the best in Latvia in his age. As a present he got a permit to go and visit Eastern Germany. Everybody envyed him very much. But... the visit to Eastern Germany coincided with exams in Academy of Arts where he wanted to study. And in these times - if you did not enter the highschool after completion of school, you were drawn in Soviet Army with high chances to die in Afghanistan or just from beating of fellow "comrades".
Without much thinking he decided to go to Eastern Germany - he missed his highschool and had to spend 2 years in humiliating conditions in Soviet Army for this. But he was happy about his decision then.
Such luxury as visit to Western Germany was beyond the wildest dreams.
Glad to see that Eastern Europe is a part of the open, global economy now. Your children will see the world as boundless, and even space too.
bgplayer19 November 26th, 2007, 11:41 AM We(Bulgaria) are looking forward to join Schengen in 2-3 years and adopt the Euro together with Estonia,Latvia and Lithuania:banana:
ChrisZwolle November 26th, 2007, 12:06 PM I don't think you guys will adopt the Euro very soon. There are strict regulations for that.
eomer November 26th, 2007, 03:20 PM I don't think you guys will adopt the Euro very soon. There are strict regulations for that.
Bulgaria is not so far from Euro and Shengen...
There are "only" little troubles with corruption to solve but Bulgaria made lot of efforts during the 3 last years.
Stifler November 26th, 2007, 03:33 PM Bulgaria is not so far from Euro and Shengen...
There are "only" little troubles with corruption to solve but Bulgaria made lot of efforts during the 3 last years.
And inflation. Nobody can join the Eurozone with an inflation over 10%.
Their expected date to join in 2010 but I think 2012 is more realistic.
RawLee November 26th, 2007, 04:25 PM during the 3 last years.
Bulgaria joined this year,if you're talking about that...
Rebasepoiss November 26th, 2007, 04:33 PM And inflation. Nobody can join the Eurozone with an inflation over 10%.
Their expected date to join in 2010 but I think 2012 is more realistic.
Inflation has to be under 4% so I don't think Euro will come to Bulgaria for 2012. For Estonia it was planned to join the Euro zone in 2007, but at the moment anything before 2013 will be great.
ChrisZwolle November 26th, 2007, 04:44 PM Inflation isn't necessary bad, because in Eastern European countries, prices increase, but also the income. But a low inflation is a good sign for a decent economy.
Qwert November 26th, 2007, 06:05 PM Beat this - Slovakia 2006: Core inflation 2.7%, GDP growth 8.3%.:cheers:
Source: http://ekonomika.etrend.sk/14495/slovensko/slovensko-v-ekonomickych-cislach
However, ECB will certainly find something to keep us out of Eurozone.:ohno:
keber November 26th, 2007, 09:13 PM Beat this - Slovakia 2006: Core inflation 2.7%, GDP growth 8.3%.
That's good. And you are already in ERM II. Now compare to Slovenia after almost one year of euro: cca 5% growth, but cca 5% inflation (actually prices went much more nuts, but statistics don't show that)
Qwert November 26th, 2007, 11:46 PM That's good. And you are already in ERM II. Now compare to Slovenia after almost one year of euro: cca 5% growth, but cca 5% inflation (actually prices went much more nuts, but statistics don't show that)
I think the same or even worse could expect Slovakia after possible joining of Eurozone.
Club_Dru November 27th, 2007, 01:31 AM I hope te new E.U. members increase their economie in a few years and join the Euro. And if they create a strong national economy, the 100.000 east-Europeans in Holland can go back to work in their own countries again. The open borders causes a lot of problems with migrants from the new EU-members. That's why the majority of Dutch voters, voted 'no' against Europe.
Not every migrants causes problems, but most of the Dutch are afraid to lose their jobs. So in my opinion they must close the borders again.
ChrisZwolle November 27th, 2007, 09:07 AM ^^ That's what they tell you on TV. They take jobs Dutch people think themselves they are too good for it.
And did you really think those Poles with a low income would live in an upscale neighborhood? Ofcourse not. This is all something we could have known.
Well, i think, with the increase of economy and income in Poland, i think they will return to Poland soon, because they are being exploited here, with wages under the official minimum income. I think they are better off in Poland within a few years.
mojaBL November 27th, 2007, 09:08 AM I hope te new E.U. members increase their economie in a few years and join the Euro. And if they create a strong national economy, the 100.000 east-Europeans in Holland can go back to work in their own countries again. The open borders causes a lot of problems with migrants from the new EU-members. That's why the majority of Dutch voters, voted 'no' against Europe.
Not every migrants causes problems, but most of the Dutch are afraid to lose their jobs. So in my opinion they must close the borders again.
if there were no immigrants and cheap labor from east, Holland wouldn´t be that successful and rich. So praise them every day!
igorlan November 27th, 2007, 12:39 PM if there were no immigrants and cheap labor from east, Holland wouldn´t be that successful and rich. So praise them every day!
Great reasoning :cheers:
AUchamps November 27th, 2007, 02:11 PM if there were no immigrants and cheap labor from east, Holland wouldn´t be that successful and rich. So praise them every day!
Sounds like Eastern European labor is to Western Europe as Mexican labor is to the USA.
Only difference is, your labor isn't illegally in your nations(but the wages they're getting are below the minimum wages mandated by law)
Jonesy55 November 27th, 2007, 02:27 PM ^^ Only a few people employed by unscrupulous employers get less than the legal minimum, most East Europeans here in the UK at least get at the national minimum wage or more. The fact that they are legal makes it more likely that they will complain to the authorities if they are being mistreated.
mojaBL November 27th, 2007, 05:12 PM ^^ Only a few people employed by unscrupulous employers get less than the legal minimum, most East Europeans here in the UK at least get at the national minimum wage or more. The fact that they are legal makes it more likely that they will complain to the authorities if they are being mistreated.
i don´t think so coz they are affraid to do that. And authorities will surely protect the dutchs over some foreigners, meaning they will surely stay blind and deaf.
bgplayer19 November 27th, 2007, 10:19 PM Inflation has to be under 4% so I don't think Euro will come to Bulgaria for 2012. For Estonia it was planned to join the Euro zone in 2007, but at the moment anything before 2013 will be great.
At the moment our inflation is 4.6% and if you check the timetable in Wikipedia you will see that we have filled every criteria except one thing which i can't remember right now!Also we are researching our EURO coin and soon it will be announced!The date of adopting the EURO is 2009 along with Estonia,Latvia and Lithuania i think
Stifler November 28th, 2007, 12:50 AM At the moment our inflation is 4.6% and if you check the timetable in Wikipedia you will see that we have filled every criteria except one thing which i can't remember right now!Where have you seen that data? Bulgaria's inflation in October was 10.6% (link (http://epp.eurostat.ec.europa.eu/pls/portal/docs/PAGE/PGP_PRD_CAT_PREREL/PGE_CAT_PREREL_YEAR_2007/PGE_CAT_PREREL_YEAR_2007_MONTH_11/2-15112007-EN-AP.PDF)). The other statement is right. You have a low debt and deficit so it won't be a problem to join the Eurozone. You just need to keep your inflation below 4%, something not easy in a booming economy.
ADCS November 28th, 2007, 01:18 AM One thing you have to take into account is that most W. European cars have to be checked at the Bulgarian border to make sure that the headlights don't put out too much light. The extreme shininess of the Struma's crashbarriers would otherwise cause innumerable accidents.
DanielFigFoz November 28th, 2007, 03:10 PM One thing you have to take into account is that most W. European cars have to be checked at the Bulgarian border to make sure that the headlights don't put out too much light. The extreme shininess of the Struma's crashbarriers would otherwise cause innumerable accidents.
:lol:
Slartibartfas November 28th, 2007, 10:55 PM i don´t think so coz they are affraid to do that. And authorities will surely protect the dutchs over some foreigners, meaning they will surely stay blind and deaf.
If thats done systematically and they get once to the wrong one, that will end up at the European court of Justice due to discrimination.
Just a question of time.
Maxx☢Power November 28th, 2007, 11:07 PM Sounds like Eastern European labor is to Western Europe as Mexican labor is to the USA.
Only difference is, your labor isn't illegally in your nations(but the wages they're getting are below the minimum wages mandated by law)
Not at all the same thing.
Hm, am I having a deja vu?
RawLee November 28th, 2007, 11:38 PM If thats done systematically and they get once to the wrong one, that will end up at the European court of Justice due to discrimination.
Just a question of time.
Just like the austrian motorway police,that uses the excuse "opposing the enforcement",when a hungarian doesnt speak german,and fines them to thousands of euros?
wyqtor November 28th, 2007, 11:44 PM Just like the austrian motorway police,that uses the excuse "opposing the enforcement",when a hungarian doesnt speak german,and fines them to thousands of euros?
OMG, do they really do that??? :shocked:
Qwert November 28th, 2007, 11:54 PM Just like the austrian motorway police,that uses the excuse "opposing the enforcement",when a hungarian doesnt speak german,and fines them to thousands of euros?
That's Austrians. For many of them is everybody from Ostblock at least mass murderer.:ohno:
RawLee November 28th, 2007, 11:54 PM OMG, do they really do that??? :shocked:
Not the first case,that I've read,although I've myself was never fined...neither home,nor abroad. Though they only use it when there is a basis for the inspection(like speeding),but they use this excuse to raise the fine. At least,that what I've read...
http://index.hu/cikkepek/0711/bulvar/schwechat/2007_05_21_140euro.jpg
http://index.hu/cikkepek/0711/bulvar/schwechat/2007_06_12_hatalyvesztes01.jpg
http://index.hu/cikkepek/0711/bulvar/schwechat/2007_06_01_feljelentes01.jpg
http://index.hu/cikkepek/0711/bulvar/schwechat/2007_05_21_jogositvany.jpg
just some examples of the latest case.
ChrisZwolle December 20th, 2007, 07:56 PM Slovakia, Austria kick off Schengen expansion party
BERG-PETRZALKA CROSSING, Austria-Slovakia border (AFP) — Slovakia and Austria on Thursday launched ceremonies to extend the European Union's passport-free Schengen zone to nine mainly ex-East bloc countries seeking to shed their communist pasts.
Austrian Chancellor Alfred Gusenbauer and Slovak Prime Minister Robert Fico cut down the frontier barrier between their two countries at the Berg/Petrzalka crossing point to start three days of commemorations for the landmark change.
The addition of the Czech Republic, Estonia, Hungary, Latvia, Lithuania, Malta, Poland, Slovakia and Slovenia to the Schengen Treaty zone will take the number of countries involved to 24 with a total population of 400 million.
The expansion from Friday will lift border controls between the former communist states of eastern Europe and their Western neighbours and bring down internal controls in a zone stretching from Spain to Estonia.
"We are standing here at the border between Bratislava and Vienna to take away the most important symbolic barrier," said Fico.
The Austrian and Slovak capitals are just 40 kilometres (25 miles) apart but Fico added: "From midnight tonight, you can travel 4,000 kilometres (2,500 miles) from Tallinn in Estonia to Lisbon in Portugal without any border controls."
"When people go to Bratislava in 20 to 30 years, they will ask where the border was here at all," said Austrian leader Gusenbauer.
Concerts, fireworks and even a disco at the Petrzalka-Berg crossing were planned to mark the tearing down of the last remnants of the Iron Curtain.
Britain and Ireland have not joined Schengen and new EU members Bulgaria and Romania are not yet allowed in.
more here (http://afp.google.com/article/ALeqM5jdoUVE1D8KSI_US8bpvneiYFPG5A)
Congratulations to all Eastern Europe forumers! :banana:
wyqtor December 20th, 2007, 08:57 PM :dance:
Congratulations to all! I hope RO&BG join soon, we also don't need for corrupt and annoying customs officers anymore! :banana:
Next spring I'm going to Prague if all is well, instead of 3 borders there will be just one! :D
keber December 20th, 2007, 09:14 PM more here (http://afp.google.com/article/ALeqM5jdoUVE1D8KSI_US8bpvneiYFPG5A)
Congratulations to all Eastern Europe forumers! :banana:
Testing new border in Saturday.:cheers:
Chris_533976 December 20th, 2007, 09:48 PM Fantastic :D
Britain wont join because of pig-headedness (sorry, but thats what it is ;) ) and it isnt really sensible for Ireland to join without Britain joining :(
Mateusz December 20th, 2007, 10:15 PM Now I will not have to stand in queue on border with Germany in Olszyna or Jędrzychowice ;)
x-type December 20th, 2007, 10:45 PM Testing new border in Saturday.:cheers:
gonna be interesting at Macelj/Obrežje ;)
Republica December 20th, 2007, 10:51 PM Its just plain annoying that we dont join. Anyone know why we dont?
Also, I've got a friend who claims he's seen people travel to switzerland showign Id cards only from the UK. Is he talking crap?
At the moment at least we can travel to ireland passport free if we want.
x-type December 21st, 2007, 12:25 AM ^^Do you in the UK have ID cards? At web of Croatian Ministry of Foreign Affairs it's written that you can pass our border only with ID card
go_leafs_go02 December 21st, 2007, 07:37 AM UK isn't part of Schegen? funny, cause I never had to show my passport when crossing the Channel from England to France.
Or is this different?
ChrisZwolle December 21st, 2007, 09:36 AM Also, I've got a friend who claims he's seen people travel to switzerland showign Id cards only from the UK. Is he talking crap?
No, it is also possible with Dutch ID cards if i'm correct.
Salif December 21st, 2007, 10:02 AM Britain wont join because of pig-headedness (sorry, but thats what it is ;) ) and it isnt really sensible for Ireland to join without Britain joining :(
Indeed, I often think the decision makers think there's some sort of unspeakable evil waiting at the other side of Europe just waiting for a clear run to our country.
DanielFigFoz December 21st, 2007, 12:40 PM ^^Do you in the UK have ID cards? At web of Croatian Ministry of Foreign Affairs it's written that you can pass our border only with ID card
No, we don't.
Hamilton: I did, but on a ferry from France to Ireland no.
Chris_533976 December 21st, 2007, 01:42 PM At the moment at least we can travel to ireland passport free if we want.
Only really on ferries, if you go through an airport whilst you technically dont need a passport you'd be daft not to take one cos of the hassle you'd get.
Jonesy55 December 21st, 2007, 03:52 PM I don't think that Schengen would make a huge practical difference to the UK, you can't just drive onto the continent because there is a large stretch of water in the way, to get on a ferry or train, you have to check in and show tickets anyway so it's no extra hassle if you show a passport at the same time.
Our only land border is with the Irish Republic and that is already open a la Schengen anyway.
It's not as if there are huge queues and long delays at the ports anyway, usually you don't get stopped.
Republica December 22nd, 2007, 02:35 AM It would mean that we dont have to piss about with passport control on our international trains, and would increase the likelyhood of being able to get direct trains from other british destinations.
I flew to ireland on only my driving license and had absolutely no hassle at all.
But yeh, in the main it doesnt really make much difference. I have noticed they are much stricter now though at our passport control where they used to wave past anyone holding what looked like a british passport without opening it!
And also i believe we are party signed up to Schengen in terms of security sharing.
This is much more of a difference for these eastern european countries who has years of restricted movement and to have free borders with the rest of europe must be a great day and i'm pleased for you all!
Jeroen669 December 22nd, 2007, 10:02 AM ^^Do you in the UK have ID cards? At web of Croatian Ministry of Foreign Affairs it's written that you can pass our border only with ID card
In the Netherlands you officially can even be fined for not showing ID/passport WITHIN the borders. :nuts:
ChrisZwolle December 22nd, 2007, 10:56 AM In the Netherlands you officially can even be fined for not showing ID/passport WITHIN the borders. :nuts:
That is the case in many countries.
Jeroen669 December 22nd, 2007, 11:57 AM Ok, I didn't know that.
edolen1 December 22nd, 2007, 12:41 PM I remember when I entered the UK through Stansted Airport back in August there was a 45-min queue at the passport control, for EU citizens.. If not anything else at least that would be eliminated if the UK joined Schengen.
Maxx☢Power December 22nd, 2007, 01:04 PM ^^Do you in the UK have ID cards? At web of Croatian Ministry of Foreign Affairs it's written that you can pass our border only with ID card
The passport only serves as an ID in this case. Any official ID will do.
Britain doesn't join Schengen because they want to control (third-country) immigration, and probably a bit of good old stubbornness. Ireland would have to leave the Common Travel Area with Britain (a "mini-Schengen") to join Schengen, which of course would be very impractical. Britain takes part in the SIS data sharing part of Schengen, so they get the "bad" parts but not the good ones :|
eomer December 22nd, 2007, 01:07 PM Fantastic :D
Britain wont join because of pig-headedness (sorry, but thats what it is ;) ) and it isnt really sensible for Ireland to join without Britain joining :(
That's not so different: it's imposible to go to UK without using a plane, a boat, Eurostar or the Shuttle*. In all cases, you have to show your ID.
* Of course, you can choose to swim across the channel or to use your own boat or windsurf...but how many people do that each year ?
Slartibartfas December 22nd, 2007, 07:28 PM Just like the austrian motorway police,that uses the excuse "opposing the enforcement",when a hungarian doesnt speak german,and fines them to thousands of euros?
The first time I hear about that.
Do you have any source?
Slartibartfas December 22nd, 2007, 07:33 PM That's Austrians. For many of them is everybody from Ostblock at least mass murderer.:ohno:
You should not be so generalizing towards Austria as our damn mass tabloid, the Kronenzeitung, is towards the new EU member states and its citizens. There are many who hate that paper for the ugly xenophoby it spreads day in and out.
I hate to see how our government currently acts towards our neighbor countries like the Czech republic or Hungary. It makes me feel ashamed in fact to see how they act.
Qwert December 22nd, 2007, 07:45 PM You should not be so generalizing towards Austria as our damn mass tabloid, the Kronenzeitung, is towards the new EU member states and its citizens. There are many who hate that paper for the ugly xenophoby it spreads day in and out.
I hate to see how our government currently acts towards our neighbor countries like the Czech republic or Hungary. It makes me feel ashamed in fact to see how they act.
Well, I've written: "for many of them." I know not everybody thinks it. For example yesterday I've seen on the Slovak news television TA3 mayor of Wolfsthal who even has Slovak wife ans is speaking very well Slovak and he said it's necessary to remove borders also form people's mind. However, I don't think that deploying Austrian army near borders or forbidding to pass border crossing Moravský Svätý Ján/Hohenau at night is way how to do it.
http://myjany.sk/img/P1140456.JPG
ChrisZwolle December 22nd, 2007, 07:51 PM The attitude from Dutch media towards eastern Europe is also not that good, especially to Poles, as you read the papers, they are only drunk, creating a mess in neighborhoods and living with 15 people in one home or a van. It's really a shame, the people who criticize the most, have never actually been in those countries.
igorlan December 22nd, 2007, 09:01 PM The attitude from Dutch media towards eastern Europe is also not that good, especially to Poles, as you read the papers, they are only drunk, creating a mess in neighborhoods and living with 15 people in one home or a van. It's really a shame, the people who criticize the most, have never actually been in those countries.
No offence to anyone but Holland would be a shithold now, if it weren't the emigrants from the rest of the world. I think that Dutch media should consider it, but they seem to be very forgetful of the facts.
Slartibartfas December 23rd, 2007, 12:49 PM Well, I've written: "for many of them." I know not everybody thinks it. For example yesterday I've seen on the Slovak news television TA3 mayor of Wolfsthal who even has Slovak wife ans is speaking very well Slovak and he said it's necessary to remove borders also form people's mind.
I forgot if it was Wolfsthal, but a neighboring Austrian village to Bratislava wanted to make a large step forward in improving public transport to Bratislava now. The mayor could not expect that the Austrian post busses would not only refuse to serve that line (that was no problem they had found already someone else who would do so), but also that they forbid anyone else to serve it as they have the exclusive right of doing... what assholes... I think their is a case pending at the court because of that. I still hope that the position of the post busses is unholdable.
I don't think that deploying Austrian army near borders
This step is largely criticized in Austria as well. Simply because its a farce and probably an unconstitutional farce as well. But if I can make you feel better, their presence their is meaningless anyway, every action except calling the police committed by them would be illegal. If that not helps perhaps it helps when I tell you that the Bavarians did also rise quite overreacted border region controls when we joined Schengen in 1998. They soon came to the conclusion that its not justified.
It seems our politicians are so afraid from the Krone and her xenophobe opinion dictate over Austria that they seem to think its worth to enrage the neighbors for something that is completely senseless.
or forbidding to pass border crossing Moravský Svätý Ján/Hohenau at night is way how to do it.
http://myjany.sk/img/P1140456.JPG
Isn't that because of what the Hungarians wanted?
Maybe they even have a point, as its a nature protection area this is going through.
RawLee December 23rd, 2007, 05:24 PM The first time I hear about that.
Do you have any source?
I know only 1 case that made it to the internet. But in that case,a lawyer said its not the first. I dont know,and I dont really care. As much as I can tell from this case,they driver was speeding,so the police had legal basis to fine him(if this would happen at home,with a local,I'd even dare to say it is a good lesson for him).
BTW,on my way today coming home from eastern-Hungary,5 romanian SUVs drove over the limit,1 romanian Opel with a trailer(!!!),and a slovakian Skoda,not counting the local bullets. I dont know where is our police...:ohno:
LtBk December 23rd, 2007, 08:01 PM I know only 1 case that made it to the internet. But in that case,a lawyer said its not the first. I dont know,and I dont really care. As much as I can tell from this case,they driver was speeding,so the police had legal basis to fine him(if this would happen at home,with a local,I'd even dare to say it is a good lesson for him).
BTW,on my way today coming home from eastern-Hungary,5 romanian SUVs drove over the limit,1 romanian Opel with a trailer(!!!),and a slovakian Skoda,not counting the local bullets. I dont know where is our police...:ohno:
You do know everybody speeds right?
Slartibartfas December 23rd, 2007, 08:18 PM I know only 1 case that made it to the internet. But in that case,a lawyer said its not the first. I dont know,and I dont really care. As much as I can tell from this case,they driver was speeding,so the police had legal basis to fine him(if this would happen at home,with a local,I'd even dare to say it is a good lesson for him).
BTW,on my way today coming home from eastern-Hungary,5 romanian SUVs drove over the limit,1 romanian Opel with a trailer(!!!),and a slovakian Skoda,not counting the local bullets. I dont know where is our police...:ohno:
Well if they were too fast, then they have to be ready to pay the fine when being caught. Nothing wrong with that.
As I dont know anything about those cases, if they were forced to pay more than the original fine it might be because he was so clever and thought he might get away with refusing to pay.
If its one of those things I can't see something wrong. I strongly doubt someone has to pay anything if he does not speak German. If eg a Hungarian speeder thinks he can play stupid and refuse to pay the fine than thats something different. (Even if he doesn't speak a word German or English, its possible to make him realize that he has to pay a certain fine now)
RawLee December 23rd, 2007, 10:02 PM You do know everybody speeds right?
I dont. Thats at least one.
Well if they were too fast, then they have to be ready to pay the fine when being caught. Nothing wrong with that.
As I dont know anything about those cases, if they were forced to pay more than the original fine it might be because he was so clever and thought he might get away with refusing to pay.
If its one of those things I can't see something wrong. I strongly doubt someone has to pay anything if he does not speak German. If eg a Hungarian speeder thinks he can play stupid and refuse to pay the fine than thats something different. (Even if he doesn't speak a word German or English, its possible to make him realize that he has to pay a certain fine now)
I dont know if he did try to evade the fine or not. It happened,thats what I know.
BTW,I've found the documentation of the case...on the previous page:nuts:
http://www.skyscrapercity.com/showpost.php?p=16775064&postcount=64
Qwert December 23rd, 2007, 10:38 PM I forgot if it was Wolfsthal, but a neighboring Austrian village to Bratislava wanted to make a large step forward in improving public transport to Bratislava now. The mayor could not expect that the Austrian post busses would not only refuse to serve that line (that was no problem they had found already someone else who would do so), but also that they forbid anyone else to serve it as they have the exclusive right of doing... what assholes... I think their is a case pending at the court because of that. I still hope that the position of the post busses is unholdable.
Transport company of Bratislava wants to serve Wolfsthal and Hainburg, but some Austrian company refuses it because it has exlusive rights there. However, there is already bus connection of those little towns with Bratislava operated by company Slovak Lines.
This step is largely criticized in Austria as well. Simply because its a farce and probably an unconstitutional farce as well. But if I can make you feel better, their presence their is meaningless anyway, every action except calling the police committed by them would be illegal. If that not helps perhaps it helps when I tell you that the Bavarians did also rise quite overreacted border region controls when we joined Schengen in 1998. They soon came to the conclusion that its not justified.
It seems our politicians are so afraid from the Krone and her xenophobe opinion dictate over Austria that they seem to think its worth to enrage the neighbors for something that is completely senseless.
I think it's populism from Austrian governemnt. I know those soldiers can do nothing. But, as some Austrians can appreciate it, some people in new Schengen countries can consider it as an offence.
Isn't that because of what the Hungarians wanted?
Maybe they even have a point, as its a nature protection area this is going through.
Moravský Svätý Ján/Hohenau is very far from Hungary. It's small border crossing between Austria and Slovakia close to the Czech border. Here is map: http://maps.google.com/maps/ms?ie=UTF8&hl=en&msa=0&ll=48.601864,16.934674&spn=0.077987,0.159645&z=13&om=1&msid=103736049826817828962.000441fa9e994a505d37e Maybe it's due to protection fo nature, but why it was placed there on the day when Schengen was extended? The traffic there is very low, at night almost no and without trucks so I can see no point there. Both banks of river Morava are protected area. Niderosterreich offcials wanted Slovak officials to do the same, but they refused to do so.
RawLee December 23rd, 2007, 10:57 PM Some interesting numbers from the new outer borders:
in the last 60 hours,border guards caught:
20 trespassers,out of which 19 tried to get into the Schengen zone,and 1 out:nuts:
1 people smuggler
20 fake documents(romanian and bulgarian IDs and fake EU visas)
37 people who are banned from the Schengen zone
1 person missing
11 wanted criminals
many stolen cars and licence plates too.
There are bad news too. 20 trucks can get out in an hour to Ukraine,and 500 are waiting.
Qwert December 23rd, 2007, 11:33 PM I recommend to watch this video form Schnegen border between Slovakia and Ukraine: http://www.sme.sk/video/?id=2351
Rebasepoiss December 23rd, 2007, 11:36 PM ^^ The only bad thing we've had is that one people who was forbidden to entry Estonia still managed to do it, but that's it.
ChrisZwolle December 23rd, 2007, 11:44 PM Hmmm somehow it kinda feels like to me that the iron curtain still exist, only now it forms the outer borders of Schengen.
Though i am glad with the current expansion of Schengen, it makes trade and national markets in eastern europe much more accessible, something that will work out for everybody's welfare in the future, though we (= western Europe) are now struggling with a lot of work immigrants from especially Poland, but that's just a temporary phase i think.
Overtime, when Poland economy will reach the same welfare level as in western Europe, this work immigration will end. We went through the same in late 80's when Spain and Portugal joined the EU. This is just a matter of time and patience.
I hope they will have that patience in Eastern Europe too, sometimes you read about people expecting to have the same welfare as in Western Europe within a few years. That might not be true, it takes time, we (=western/northern Europe) worked for decades to reach the welfare level we have now.
edolen1 December 24th, 2007, 12:08 AM The Schengen border poses a problem for many second-hand car owners as well.. You may find out the car you legally bought was actually stolen, it's happened to many Czechs and Slovaks which tried to cross the Slovenian-Croatian border after we started implementing the system back in August.. And if your car is stolen, you aren't getting it back..
Dan December 24th, 2007, 07:24 AM Some interesting numbers from the new outer borders:
in the last 60 hours,border guards caught:
20 trespassers,out of which 19 tried to get into the Schengen zone,and 1 out:nuts:
1 people smuggler
20 fake documents(romanian and bulgarian IDs and fake EU visas)
37 people who are banned from the Schengen zone
1 person missing
11 wanted criminals
many stolen cars and licence plates too.
There are bad news too. 20 trucks can get out in an hour to Ukraine,and 500 are waiting.
That's kind of scary actually, and worries me a bit given that Bulgaria and Romania will be in Schengen within a few years. A lot of people thought that they weren't even ready for the EU quite yet in 2007 and should have joined in 2008. Hopefully they'll be 1000% ready for Schengen, though, before they are let in, because it's quite important for many countries.
RawLee December 24th, 2007, 09:53 AM That's kind of scary actually, and worries me a bit given that Bulgaria and Romania will be in Schengen within a few years. A lot of people thought that they weren't even ready for the EU quite yet in 2007 and should have joined in 2008. Hopefully they'll be 1000% ready for Schengen, though, before they are let in, because it's quite important for many countries.
Outer borders are Ukraine,Serbia and Croatia. Well,Romania too,but they are let through,because they are EU members...
Slartibartfas December 24th, 2007, 12:03 PM I dont. Thats at least one.
I dont know if he did try to evade the fine or not. It happened,thats what I know.
BTW,I've found the documentation of the case...on the previous page:nuts:
http://www.skyscrapercity.com/showpost.php?p=16775064&postcount=64
Reads weird. To be honest, I can't really make sense out of it, if someone would have more about those cases it would be interesting to read. I mean they write that the recepte mentioned only 140€ but the police men acknowledget that they fined 1100€. One of the former paper mentions 960€ Sicherheitsrücklage or so. No idea what this is or meant to be.
But to be honest I dont have much experience with speeder fines, never got one yet.
Slartibartfas December 24th, 2007, 12:09 PM Transport company of Bratislava wants to serve Wolfsthal and Hainburg, but some Austrian company refuses it because it has exlusive rights there. However, there is already bus connection of those little towns with Bratislava operated by company Slovak Lines.
Yes, but the other service would be considerably better and more integrated. It would be a great step forward in regards to PT service quality.
As I have said, there is a court case pending as far as I know. I hope that the Postbus has no chance if it wants to use its exclusive right of service in order to prevent any better service.
I think it's populism from Austrian governemnt. I know those soldiers can do nothing. But, as some Austrians can appreciate it, some people in new Schengen countries can consider it as an offence.
Of course they can. But the question is if they are then cleverer than those who appreciate it.
Moravský Svätý Ján/Hohenau is very far from Hungary. It's small border crossing between Austria and Slovakia close to the Czech border. Here is map: http://maps.google.com/maps/ms?ie=UTF8&hl=en&msa=0&ll=48.601864,16.934674&spn=0.077987,0.159645&z=13&om=1&msid=103736049826817828962.000441fa9e994a505d37e Maybe it's due to protection fo nature, but why it was placed there on the day when Schengen was extended? The traffic there is very low, at night almost no and without trucks so I can see no point there. Both banks of river Morava are protected area. Niderosterreich offcials wanted Slovak officials to do the same, but they refused to do so.
Oh.
Well I can't comment on this specific case as I have not the slightest information about it.
Sounds a bit like the case with Hungary just the other way round. But I can err.
ChrisZwolle December 24th, 2007, 12:11 PM That's kind of scary actually, and worries me a bit given that Bulgaria and Romania will be in Schengen within a few years. A lot of people thought that they weren't even ready for the EU quite yet in 2007 and should have joined in 2008. Hopefully they'll be 1000% ready for Schengen, though, before they are let in, because it's quite important for many countries.
I agree, in my opinion, there should be some same level of welfare, corruption, economy and income between Schengen countries. I don't think those 2 countries are there yet. I also had my doubts with Lithuania and Latvia, but i understand there would be some impractical situations then.
And today, i read this story about Romanian parents from the poor countryside leave their children to work in Italy and Spain, and i think this kind of stuff shouldn't happen in the EU or schengen. I understand the situation in these countries and their need for economic growth, but when your workforce leaves the country, how can you accomplish economic growth? I understand the motives for those people who want to work in Western Europe, but i also understand the resistance to all this from western Europe towards these countries.
To be frank, i think Romania and Bulgaria entered too soon, sure i would adjudge them economic profits from entering the EU, but things have to work both ways.
I think the EU should wait for further eastern europe expansion (except Croatia), until the now eastern European EU countries have a higher level of welfare
Slartibartfas December 24th, 2007, 12:11 PM Some interesting numbers from the new outer borders:
in the last 60 hours,border guards caught:
20 trespassers,out of which 19 tried to get into the Schengen zone,and 1 out:nuts:
.
:lol:
Was he a looked after criminal or just an idiot?
Slartibartfas December 24th, 2007, 12:22 PM The Schengen border poses a problem for many second-hand car owners as well.. You may find out the car you legally bought was actually stolen, it's happened to many Czechs and Slovaks which tried to cross the Slovenian-Croatian border after we started implementing the system back in August.. And if your car is stolen, you aren't getting it back..
Is this a consequence out of being part of the SIS system?
Cool.
Just one question, where are those Czechs and Slovaks buying their cars? At least according to Austrian law they could hold themselves free of any financial damage if they could not expect that they buy a stolen car. In fact the trader would be the target of illegal dealer accusations then.
I would say, mind the the papers of the primary owner, if they are correct, its fine, if they are forged in a way that you can't find out that they are forged you are fine as well, because then the former owner has a problem.
ChrisZwolle December 24th, 2007, 12:29 PM The A1 in the Netherlands is one large flow of Polish, Russian, Belorussian and Ukranian cars with trailers with new cars towards the east.
RawLee December 24th, 2007, 12:32 PM :lol:
Was he a looked after criminal or just an idiot?
That wasnt in the article:)
An article on a site of a county,they wrote that at Röszke(motorway border with Serbia),there were 5 people caught who were banned from Schengen zone,2 tried to get in,3 tried to leave. Of the 5, 2 was reported from Germany,1-1 from Austria,CZ and Hungary.
Qwert December 24th, 2007, 02:19 PM Yes, but the other service would be considerably better and more integrated. It would be a great step forward in regards to PT service quality.
As I have said, there is a court case pending as far as I know. I hope that the Postbus has no chance if it wants to use its exclusive right of service in order to prevent any better service.
Such service would be good, beacuse those buses will drive regulary no mather if full or empty. Not like present buses which even don't stop there if there's no reservation. It's ridiculous, Wolfsthal is some 9 km form the center of Bratislava, but it's complicated to get there without car.
Of course they can. But the question is if they are then cleverer than those who appreciate it.
I don't think it's question of cleverness. It's just completely useless step.
Oh.
Well I can't comment on this specific case as I have not the slightest information about it.
Sounds a bit like the case with Hungary just the other way round. But I can err.
It's quite an issue here. It was also in the TV news yesterday and all Slovak dailys informed about it. They all consider it as an offence and discrimination. It can cause a lot of problems since many people travel there from or to work, there are cultural events on both side of river with attendance from both banks and it's wierd to end them before 22:00. Another problem is it's just 30 metres form the end of the one way bridge on one way road where is not possible to turn your car without violating the law. What they protect those 30 metres?
Slartibartfas December 24th, 2007, 04:36 PM Such service would be good, beacuse those buses will drive regulary no mather if full or empty. Not like present buses which even don't stop there if there's no reservation. It's ridiculous, Wolfsthal is some 9 km form the center of Bratislava, but it's complicated to get there without car.
I knew it was bad, I had forgot already that it was this much of a joke...
That does not even deserve the name "public transport"
I don't think it's question of cleverness. It's just completely useless step.
Not for our politicians, but in terms of rational thinkingh. Yes.
I would only hope our neighbors are able to take it rationally and see that its nothing they have to care about as its just the regularely inner Austrian hilarious comedy theater called "politics".
It's quite an issue here. It was also in the TV news yesterday and all Slovak dailys informed about it. They all consider it as an offence and discrimination. It can cause a lot of problems since many people travel there from or to work, there are cultural events on both side of river with attendance from both banks and it's wierd to end them before 22:00. Another problem is it's just 30 metres form the end of the one way bridge on one way road where is not possible to turn your car without violating the law. What they protect those 30 metres?
Why don't we get those news here at all? We only can read in our Krone about how every one from the new member states is at least a car thief ... :ohno:
Qwert December 24th, 2007, 04:59 PM I knew it was bad, I had forgot already that it was this much of a joke...
That does not even deserve the name "public transport"
Yes, that public transport is like joke. From those villages is easier to get to Vienna than to Bratislava which is some 5 km from them.
Not for our politicians, but in terms of rational thinkingh. Yes.
I would only hope our neighbors are able to take it rationally and see that its nothing they have to care about as its just the regularely inner Austrian hilarious comedy theater called "politics".
I've said it, I consider it populistic step. It's sad, but it's true that you can acquire popularity by this.:ohno:
Why don't we get those news here at all? We only can read in our Krone about how every one from the new member states is at least a car thief ... :ohno:
Well, everybody should definitely stop reading tabloids.;) IMO people who read them should not have right to vote at elections.:D Old Greeks would call them idiotés. For me is disgusting enough even when I see some commercial on tabloids on the TV.
igorlan December 24th, 2007, 07:44 PM http://slutowo.com/skyscraper/23122007673.jpg
Originally Posted by maciek2000
From polish subforum. more here: http://www.skyscrapercity.com/showthread.php?t=192637
Slartibartfas December 24th, 2007, 08:29 PM Yes, that public transport is like joke. From those villages is easier to get to Vienna than to Bratislava which is some 5 km from them.
Why doesn't surprise me that?
I've said it, I consider it populistic step. It's sad, but it's true that you can acquire popularity by this.:ohno:
Thats exactly what its all about, being a populistic step. Its not sure however that people who read the Krone will be satisfied by it as they may realize its fake nature. They may prefer the idea of reestablishing the iron curtain again :ohno: At least thats what I get sometimes the impression of.
Qwert December 24th, 2007, 09:57 PM Why doesn't surprise me that?
It wouldn't be surprise before a couple of years, but now such things should be over.
Slartibartfas December 25th, 2007, 03:09 PM It wouldn't be surprise before a couple of years, but now such things should be over.
Walls in the minds of the people survive a long time you must know...
Qwert December 25th, 2007, 05:19 PM Walls in the minds of the people survive a long time you must know...
I know, even 20 years is not enough.
Slartibartfas December 25th, 2007, 05:36 PM I know, even 20 years is not enough.
In an Austrian forum I read an interesting comment.
With the fall of the iron curtain and the reemergance of a Central Europe we have reached the state that was so common until 89 years ago: The peoples in a common borderless central Europe being eager in building (mental) walls...
The time when a real iron curtain caused people to demand a fall of those borders was nearly too achronistic to be true...
Hopefully this comment remains to be only cynism and not a fitting picture of reality.
Qwert December 25th, 2007, 07:06 PM In an Austrian forum I read an interesting comment.
With the fall of the iron curtain and the reemergance of a Central Europe we have reached the state that was so common until 89 years ago: The peoples in a common borderless central Europe being eager in building (mental) walls...
The time when a real iron curtain caused people to demand a fall of those borders was nearly too achronistic to be true...
Hopefully this comment remains to be only cynism and not a fitting picture of reality.
In the Iron courtain times, there were not so big problems with illegal immigration and so on in Austria. People were used to the world ending behind the courtain. But, this "luxurious" world disapperad from day to day. Austrians were probably the nation which life was changed most by fall of socialism, after socialistic countries of course. And many of those changes vere rather negative and very quick. But, this transformation era is very close to the end. The transformation of people's minds will, however, last for longer time.
Slartibartfas December 26th, 2007, 12:50 PM In the Iron courtain times, there were not so big problems with illegal immigration and so on in Austria. People were used to the world ending behind the courtain. But, this "luxurious" world disapperad from day to day. Austrians were probably the nation which life was changed most by fall of socialism, after socialistic countries of course. And many of those changes vere rather negative and very quick. But, this transformation era is very close to the end. The transformation of people's minds will, however, last for longer time.
I agree to you that Austria has been effected heavily. But I want to add something:
The consequences in the public opinion have been rather negative, while in hard numbers and also the opinion of enterpreneurs (not only the large but also many small ones) it has been very postive. In fact in economic terms the last 15 years were a little success story for Austria. Especially Vienna profitated a lot.
I can only hope that you are correct, that we will see in the years to come the transformation of people's minds. Hopefully I it will happen in my lifetime.
Qwert December 26th, 2007, 12:56 PM I agree to you that Austria has been effected heavily. But I want to add something:
The consequences in the public opinion have been rather negative, while in hard numbers and also the opinion of enterpreneurs (not only the large but also many small ones) it has been very postive. In fact in economic terms the last 15 years were a little success story for Austria. Especially Vienna profitated a lot.
I can only hope that you are correct, that we will see in the years to come the transformation of people's minds. Hopefully I it will happen in my lifetime.
Economically it was very positive. However, people are everywhere sensing rather nagative things. I hope as well their minds will change quickly. I think we must wait until the welfare and especially wages will be very similar in EU.
Slartibartfas December 26th, 2007, 01:02 PM Economically it was very positive. However, people are everywhere sensing rather nagative things. I hope as well their minds will change quickly. I think we must wait until the welfare and especially wages will be very similar in EU.
Funnily it makes itself already to the news that in the meanwhile more Czech, Slovaks and Hungarians are going shopping to Austria than the other way round.
I am surprised to see that this has not collided with the prejudices Austrians still have.
PS:
Does anyone know what is a nicer place to visit. Cesky Krumlov, Brno or Plzen?
vlker December 26th, 2007, 08:17 PM PS:
Does anyone know what is a nicer place to visit. Cesky Krumlov, Brno or Plzen?
Cesky krumlov is beautiful medieval town. I can recommend to you...But there's a mass of foreign tourists, especially Japanese and so on...so the best season could be winter, if you don't like crowds of tourists. Plzen is quite nice and there is the best beer i've had:cheers: But on the other hand, it's just a normal city with shiny city center. But if you like wine, I would recommend you Brno-it's capital of south moravia with many wineyards and cellars in the south of Brno and very nice country with canyons, caves and so on in the north.
Slartibartfas December 27th, 2007, 11:41 AM Cesky krumlov is beautiful medieval town. I can recommend to you...But there's a mass of foreign tourists, especially Japanese and so on...so the best season could be winter, if you don't like crowds of tourists. Plzen is quite nice and there is the best beer i've had:cheers: But on the other hand, it's just a normal city with shiny city center. But if you like wine, I would recommend you Brno-it's capital of south moravia with many wineyards and cellars in the south of Brno and very nice country with canyons, caves and so on in the north.
Thats fine, Brno is the one of the three that is located closer than the other two. My former chemistry teacher was born in Brno as well.
I did not know about the wine though. I am surprised :)
Cesky Krumlov sounds a bit like Salzburg... well Salzburg is not medieval but for the rest.
Qwert December 27th, 2007, 06:45 PM Thats fine, Brno is the one of the three that is located closer than the other two. My former chemistry teacher was born in Brno as well.
I did not know about the wine though. I am surprised :)
I didin't hear about wine exactly in Brno, but Brno is capital of Southern Moravia where is plenty of very good vineyards so I can only recommend to visit some cellars in countryside.
Slartibartfas December 27th, 2007, 07:00 PM I didin't hear about wine exactly in Brno, but Brno is capital of Southern Moravia where is plenty of very good vineyards so I can only recommend to visit some cellars in countryside.
I am more of a beer drinker though ;) But I imagine that there doesn't exist a place in the entire Czech Republic which would be bad for beer drinkers ;)
I only know the Starobrno brand so far. You get it in Austria as well in some restaurants.
RawLee December 27th, 2007, 07:05 PM I am more of a beer drinker though ;) But I imagine that there doesn't exist a place in the entire Czech Republic which would be bad for beer drinkers ;)
I only know the Starobrno brand so far. You get it in Austria as well in some restaurants.
You dont know Kozel???:ohno:
Qwert December 27th, 2007, 07:20 PM I am more of a beer drinker though ;) But I imagine that there doesn't exist a place in the entire Czech Republic which would be bad for beer drinkers ;)
I only know the Starobrno brand so far. You get it in Austria as well in some restaurants.
Well, you can buy beer in every village, in every pub, but I thing that's possible in every country.
You dont know Kozel???:ohno:
And what about Pilsner and Budweisser, probably the most famous Czech brands?
DanielFigFoz December 27th, 2007, 08:46 PM Well, you can buy beer in every village, in every pub, but I thing that's possible in every country.
And what about Pilsner and Budweisser, probably the most famous Czech brands?
Budwisser is not the American Budwiser to all you people out there.
Kampflamm December 27th, 2007, 08:48 PM It's actually Budweiser.
ChrisZwolle December 27th, 2007, 08:51 PM Budwisser is not the American Budwiser to all you people out there.
Did you used to be DFM our Portuguese friend? :)
all those name changes :lol:
Bahnsteig4 December 27th, 2007, 08:56 PM It's actually Budweiser.
It is indeed, and I have a can in front of me as I write. :cheers:
Now, any pictures of the SI/HR border? I imagine it's pretty terrible. Especially in Portoroz... (Sorry I don't have that letter on my Germanocentric keyboard.)
Qwert December 27th, 2007, 09:22 PM It's actually Budweiser.
Oh sorry, in Czech republic it's Budějovický Budvar or shorter Budvar.;)
Slartibartfas December 28th, 2007, 12:38 PM Oh sorry, in Czech republic it's Budějovický Budvar or shorter Budvar.;)
The brand label in Austria says "Budweiser-Budvar". Do they have a different brand label in the Czech Republic?
http://www.neilwiltshire.com/ebay/budvar.gif
Slartibartfas December 28th, 2007, 12:45 PM You dont know Kozel???:ohno:
Kozel, doesnt come from Brno, does it?
But no, I did not know that brand. I am not extremely educated about Bohemian beers. But I like Budweiser-Budvar and Pilsener Urquell. Starobrno is not among my favorites but not bad either.
Qwert December 28th, 2007, 03:34 PM The brand label in Austria says "Budweiser-Budvar". Do they have a different brand label in the Czech Republic?
http://www.neilwiltshire.com/ebay/budvar.gif
As far as I know, in Czech republic is used brand Budějovický Budvar. But, to be honest, I've never seen its bottle in Czech republic, only glass.:lol:
http://www.budvar.cz/img/boxy/Znacka-Budvar/Znamka-Budvar/20.gif
Kozel, doesnt come from Brno, does it?
But no, I did not know that brand. I am not extremely educated about Bohemian beers. But I like Budweiser-Budvar and Pilsener Urquell. Starobrno is not among my favorites but not bad either.
Full name of Kozel is Velkopopovický Kozel, so it's from Velké Popovice what is some 20 km from Prague.
Bahnsteig4 December 28th, 2007, 04:28 PM ^^ In some select resturants and pubs you might get it. I know at least two. Is Staropramen from CZ or SK?
Slartibartfas December 28th, 2007, 04:33 PM ^^ In some select resturants and pubs you might get it. I know at least two. Is Staropramen from CZ or SK?
Google says its a beer from Prague, therefor I let you guess the country ;)
Bahnsteig4 December 28th, 2007, 05:44 PM Hmmmmm, tough.
Slartibartfas December 28th, 2007, 09:01 PM Hmmmmm, tough.
I grant you a telephone joker. You can ask this expert on geography ...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=juOQhTuzDQ0
(no, not the 5th grader boy, I mean of course the girl)
;)
DanielFigFoz December 28th, 2007, 09:10 PM Did you used to be DFM our Portuguese friend? :)
all those name changes :lol:
That's me :cheers:
Bahnsteig4 December 28th, 2007, 09:14 PM Must be Europe then. But is Europe the capital of Prague? Or is it Bratislava?
Or even Portugl?
DanielFigFoz December 28th, 2007, 09:22 PM "Nah I think that in Japan they speak Urdu. In Mexico they speak Mexican and in... wait! I know what they speak in Prage! Afrikanns, of course! Why did'nt I think of that.
-----------------------
Anyway, like I said this is great news!
igorlan December 30th, 2007, 07:41 PM ^^
Aren't you guys going a bit off topic???? :)
dhlennon December 30th, 2007, 08:58 PM very off-topic but beer is good (unless driving) :)
Slartibartfas December 30th, 2007, 08:58 PM What was it about again... ?
Oh, Schenge. A great thing indeed.
I am looking forward already when the new member states are becoming true and full members with getting also the fundamental basic right of free movement after the border controls fell already.
RawLee January 5th, 2008, 04:45 PM Check this:
An austrian car was stopped few kms inside Hungary after Hegyeshalom. There were guns,3rd reich documents,SS-rings and a memorial medal issued on Hitler's birthday in 1945 in the car. The guy told the police he had a house in the Rábaköz area in Hungary. There,police had found a shotgun and 683 other types of guns. He didnt have permission for them. Experts say they are all older than 50 years,so he is now suspected with illegal possession of guns and cultural materials. He is in custody currently.
Kampflamm January 5th, 2008, 05:00 PM I told dad not to keep that stuff in his car. :rant:
Slartibartfas January 5th, 2008, 05:04 PM Check this:
An austrian car was stopped few kms inside Hungary after Hegyeshalom. There were guns,3rd reich documents,SS-rings and a memorial medal issued on Hitler's birthday in 1945 in the car. The guy told the police he had a house in the Rábaköz area in Hungary. There,police had found a shotgun and 683 other types of guns. He didnt have permission for them. Experts say they are all older than 50 years,so he is now suspected with illegal possession of guns and cultural materials. He is in custody currently.
Well, he can be lucky he has not been caught by the Austrian police. But if I think about it, it probably doesn't make a difference, as Austria will call for his extradition if Hungarian laws on this are not even harsher...
RawLee January 5th, 2008, 05:26 PM One can wonder,how long he has been doing this,if he managed to collect 683 guns in his house...
Raf11 January 5th, 2008, 05:28 PM One can wonder,how long he has been doing this,if he managed to collect 683 guns in his house...
Ask Kampflamm ;)
Qwert January 5th, 2008, 05:30 PM One can wonder,how long he has been doing this,if he managed to collect 683 guns in his house...
Some people are collectiong stamps, some guns, some old nazi artefacts... People have various hobby.:D
Raf11 January 5th, 2008, 05:34 PM Some people are collectiong stamps, some guns, some old nazi artefacts... People have various hobby.:D
Right. Some people are planting grass f.e. What a world! You mustn't do this, you mustn't do that...
Slartibartfas January 5th, 2008, 05:47 PM One can wonder,how long he has been doing this,if he managed to collect 683 guns in his house...
Depends on how clever he was to hide his activity.
But whats the point anyway? Its not like Austria would be the sole country who has to endure right extreme assholes.
RawLee January 5th, 2008, 06:06 PM Depends on how clever he was to hide his activity.
But whats the point anyway? Its not like Austria would be the sole country who has to endure right extreme assholes.
Of course not! I've just posted this because I've found it funny:) you dont hear every day about a 58 year old grandpa' smuggling WWII weapons:)
Slartibartfas January 5th, 2008, 07:07 PM Of course not! I've just posted this because I've found it funny:) you dont hear every day about a 58 year old grandpa' smuggling WWII weapons:)
Perhaps he wanted to conquer the east in a one man operation? A combination of seeing too many Goebbels movies and Rambo movies? :nuts:;)
Verso November 27th, 2008, 10:31 AM Swiss to enter EU no borders zone on December 12
25 November 2008, 16:55 CET
(BRUSSELS) - Controls at the land borders between European Union nations and Switzerland will end on December 12, while controls at airports will stop on March 29, the EU's French presidency announced Tuesday.
The decision allowing Switzerland into Europe's Schengen passport-free zone will be formalised on Thursday at a meeting of EU interior ministers in Brussels, said a diplomat from France, which currently holds the bloc's rotating presidency.
Switzerland, which is not an EU member state, voted in a 2005 referendum to join the Schengen area.
It would become the 25th member of the zone, which also includes non-EU countries Iceland and Norway.
http://www.eubusiness.com/news-eu/1227626221.88
Welcome! :cheers:
Slartibartfas November 27th, 2008, 01:26 PM Welcome to Schengen Switzerland. The border controls sucked as hell anyway ;)
Iemand November 27th, 2008, 01:40 PM Liechtenstein?
Slartibartfas November 27th, 2008, 01:49 PM Liechtenstein?
Does not join. Not yet. That causes some problems indeed for Switzerlands relations to Liechtenstein.
Dan November 27th, 2008, 03:07 PM Really, they're not joining yet? Howcome?
Morsue November 27th, 2008, 03:13 PM Liechtenstein will be an interesting issue, time to work out their differences with the Czechs and Slovaks? Another interesting issue will be the Eurairport on French soil but closer to Basel than to Mulhouse. Right now there is a road connecting from Switzerland directly to the Swiss part of the airport without passing any customs checks. Indeed, there is a customs check inside the airport between the Swiss and French part. I wonder if this will be changed somehow.
Verso November 27th, 2008, 04:13 PM Will now there be control on the Swiss-Liechtenstein border? :sly:
ChrisZwolle November 27th, 2008, 04:14 PM There aren't even border crossings between those countries, if I recall correctly (it's been quite a while).
Verso November 27th, 2008, 04:19 PM No, there are no border stations.
Robosteve November 27th, 2008, 04:32 PM I really like the idea of the Schengen agreement. Europe has been a place that's interested me to visit (and perhaps live) for quite some time. I think that Africa could do with a similar agreement between its various countries, not that that's likely to happen in the foreseeable future.
Bahnsteig4 November 27th, 2008, 04:41 PM Will now there be control on the Swiss-Liechtenstein border?
Seems pretty weird to me... Such a small country to be the only one within thousands of miles in every direction to demand a passport control? What's the point? Vatican city or Monaco passport controls would make just as much sense. :|
Another interesting issue will be the Eurairport on French soil but closer to Basel than to Mulhouse. Right now there is a road connecting from Switzerland directly to the Swiss part of the airport without passing any customs checks. Indeed, there is a customs check inside the airport between the Swiss and French part. I wonder if this will be changed somehow.
It will be a lot easier. ATM, there's a French and a Swiss part of the airport, IIRC. Obviously they can scrap that division now. I'll also be interested in Basel's three train stations. (SBB/DB/SNCF)[/quote]
Timon91 November 27th, 2008, 05:07 PM That Switzerland is joining is good news. Only in 2002 they joined the UN, but I guess it's difficult for Switzerland to remain completely neutral in a world like this. This will mean that Austria and Germany have no control anymore at any of their borders :cheers:
mgk920 November 27th, 2008, 05:17 PM With Switzerland now in Schengen, will we be seeing the Swiss A7 autobahn being extended to directly connect into the German A81, along with other highway connections?
:|
Mike
ChrisZwolle November 27th, 2008, 05:17 PM I think a prolongation of the A4 is more likely, the Swiss A7 would go straight through Konstanz.
Verso November 27th, 2008, 05:24 PM Actually the A4 and A7 both reach the border, but the A4 is just 2×1. I don't even know why it goes north of Schaffhausen, when the link with the German motorway A81 goes east of it (road #15). Germany will never bring any motorway to the Swiss A4 north of Schaffhausen.
ChrisZwolle November 27th, 2008, 05:26 PM ^^ No, but the German A96 reaches nearly to the Swiss border near Gottmadingen/Bietingen. The A96 connects to the north-south A81 Autobahn to Stuttgart.
Verso November 27th, 2008, 05:30 PM That's A81 too. But you probably wanted to say A98, not A96. ;)
ChrisZwolle November 27th, 2008, 05:52 PM Yeah, I didn't look at a map while posting :)
Dan November 27th, 2008, 06:41 PM Does anyone know why Liechtenstein is not joining now? The plan had been all along that they would join at the same time as Switzerland.
Dan November 28th, 2008, 03:04 PM Uh oh
http://euobserver.com/9/27189
Verso November 28th, 2008, 03:11 PM Under the agreement, Swiss authorities will drop passport checks at the land borders to Germany, France, Italy and Austria - but would have to enhance controls at the border with Liechtenstein, which is not part of the Schengen area.A lot of crime coming from Liechtenstein apparently. :nuts: Not to mention that it's completely landlocked - even doubly. :lol: And there's no airport there either. Maybe it's Liechtenstein that wants to control its border? :dunno: They didn't do it before though, their border with Austria was (is) controlled by the Swiss. :lol:
Energy2003 November 28th, 2008, 03:16 PM the thing between Austria <> Switzerland doens´t really change ...
i live here in Vorarlberg, i know it
NOW:
you get controlled cause of goods you carry with you, not as person yourself
so where´s the change
AND
you HAVE to carry your passport with you (of course) , so where´s the change ?
BTW: Liechtenstein (which is more interesting in my town) is not Schengen yet
Verso November 28th, 2008, 03:20 PM ID is enough. The change is for those with "exotic" license plates (citizenships). They were (are) also controlled as persons.
Bahnsteig4 November 28th, 2008, 03:22 PM Not only enhance, but introduce! Seems like an awful waste of money to me. Implement Schengen border controls for a just few months...
Eddard Stark November 28th, 2008, 03:28 PM That Switzerland is joining is good news. Only in 2002 they joined the UN, but I guess it's difficult for Switzerland to remain completely neutral in a world like this. This will mean that Austria and Germany have no control anymore at any of their borders :cheers:
Also France and Italy! For Italy it was kind of funny because part of the metropolitan area of Milan (extended) lies in Switzerland actually (Chiasso and surroundings)
Verso November 28th, 2008, 03:41 PM There's control on the border between France and Andorra, as well as UK (Chunnel), not to mention Brazil and Suriname. :D And San Marino controls its border with Italy every now and then. :D
Rijeka November 28th, 2008, 03:46 PM It will not be easy to blame the Swiss if they vote against free movement of workers when the EU does not want to apply it itself.
Slartibartfas November 28th, 2008, 03:48 PM It will not be easy to blame the Swiss if they vote against free movement of workers when the EU does not want to apply it itself.
What are you talking about?
The temporary limitations that are yet intact in a small number of memberstates? They are going to fall in a few years.
Rijeka November 28th, 2008, 03:52 PM Yes, precisely, I'm talking about that. A free movement of people is one of the essential elements of European integration, so I think this temporary restriction is not ok.
ChrisZwolle November 28th, 2008, 04:09 PM The Netherlands also restricts Bulgarians and Romanians from working limitless in our country.
Bahnsteig4 November 28th, 2008, 04:16 PM A free movement of people is one of the essential elements of European integration, so I think this temporary restriction is not ok.
The alternative for these countries (BG/RO) would have been to join at a later date - would have made much more sense anyway.
Verso November 28th, 2008, 04:18 PM Why would Switzerland have to allow BG&RO workers already now, when not all EU members allow them yet?
Timon91 November 28th, 2008, 05:05 PM Have Norway and Iceland got the same problem?
Rijeka November 28th, 2008, 06:52 PM I don't know, someone who knows should explain us! :) But the EU justice commissioner, Jacques Barrot, said yesterday that Switzerland will have to leave Schengen in case they vote in the referendum against the freedom of movement of workers from RO and BG. So I really don't get it, why should they allow it, and not, say, Austria, Germany or the Netherlands?
But I'm really looking forward to CH entering the Schengen area! :)
Slartibartfas November 28th, 2008, 07:19 PM I don't know, someone who knows should explain us! :) But the EU justice commissioner, Jacques Barrot, said yesterday that Switzerland will have to leave Schengen in case they vote in the referendum against the freedom of movement of workers from RO and BG. So I really don't get it, why should they allow it, and not, say, Austria, Germany or the Netherlands?
But I'm really looking forward to CH entering the Schengen area! :)
Germany Austria and as it seems Netherlands have temporary exemptions that will run out in a short time.
The EU will not accept new exemptions. Switzerland agreed before to a deal that it in exchange for being allowed to join Schengen it will create freedom of movement. If Switzerland is not ready to hold what it promised, it will face the consequences.
ardmacha November 28th, 2008, 07:33 PM Shengen means that there are no border controls. This is not connected directly with whether they can take up employment in that country.
Slartibartfas November 28th, 2008, 07:59 PM Shengen means that there are no border controls. This is not connected directly with whether they can take up employment in that country.
It is not directly connected, but it was part of the deal that Switzerland brokered with the EU. If Switzerland breaks that deal, you can't expect that the EU accepts to be fooled by them. If they break the deal, they can forget it, the entire one, ie also Schengen.
Verso November 28th, 2008, 08:02 PM I think it's more us, Schengen countries (particularly Switzerland's neighbors), that want Switzerland in the Schengen area, rather than the other way around though.
PS: there's still gonna be control on the Swiss border, not of people, but of goods
ChrisZwolle November 28th, 2008, 08:03 PM Shengen means that there are no border controls. This is not connected directly with whether they can take up employment in that country.
Schengen = Free movement op people, goods and capital. Schengen is way more than just border checks.
Germany Austria and as it seems Netherlands have temporary exemptions that will run out in a short time.
3 years is not a short time. The public opinion is somewhat against the Poles, since we don't have proper housing for them (domestic rental housing is under high pressure), they live with a lot of people in one house/apartment, which sometimes gives problems. However, we need them, even with all the gastarbeiters (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gastarbeiter) our unemployment rates are still at record lows.
Slartibartfas November 28th, 2008, 08:18 PM 3 years is not a short time. The public opinion is somewhat against the Poles, since we don't have proper housing for them (domestic rental housing is under high pressure), they live with a lot of people in one house/apartment, which sometimes gives problems. However, we need them, even with all the gastarbeiters (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gastarbeiter) our unemployment rates are still at record lows.
Well, whatever but its done after 3 years. Thats good, because the new member are full members. The freedoms are integral part of membership and a limitation of it can only be accepted in the way of transitional periods. Those periods will end in 3 years at the latest. Most member states have ended them already way before, but also the last reluctant ones have to end it in 3 years.
Thats not a matter of discussion anymore, all states have voted in favor of admission of those countries. Thats all that has to be said in this regard.
earthJoker November 28th, 2008, 08:19 PM Schengen = Free movement op people, goods and capital. Schengen is way more than just border checks.
No, there will still be controls of good on the swiss border. There are several different agreements one is Schengen, then there is Dublin, the free movement of people. All of those Switzerland will now be part of, but not of free movement of goods.
Slartibartfas November 28th, 2008, 08:20 PM I think it's more us, Schengen countries (particularly Switzerland's neighbors), that want Switzerland in the Schengen area, rather than the other way around though.
PS: there's still gonna be control on the Swiss border, not of people, but of goods
[/quote]
Thats because they are not member of the single market for some weird reasons, but as they like.
I would not be sure that the EU wants Switzerland more inside of Schengen than the other way round. Fact is there is a deal and if Switzerland breaks it, that deal is rendered meaningless and Switzerland can forget Schengen again.
ChrisZwolle November 28th, 2008, 08:21 PM Noch immer LKW Staus an die Schweizer Grenze :D
AUchamps November 29th, 2008, 06:00 AM I don't know, someone who knows should explain us! :) But the EU justice commissioner, Jacques Barrot, said yesterday that Switzerland will have to leave Schengen in case they vote in the referendum against the freedom of movement of workers from RO and BG. So I really don't get it, why should they allow it, and not, say, Austria, Germany or the Netherlands?
But I'm really looking forward to CH entering the Schengen area! :)
That would be so UN-Strumatic if they blocked BG and RO. Come on, you guys want to look at Eastern Europe the same way some view Mexico over here?
Not everyone over there is a Radi clone.(but if they are, then so be it)
Bahnsteig4 November 29th, 2008, 06:07 AM In the words of radi, the Great Master, it would be another example for "the fucking whoresons of EU"! ;)
Timon91 November 29th, 2008, 10:46 AM Yeah, I wonder how long we can keep this 'ban' for RO and BG workers. We've had most of the Poles now and there were some problems, but we can cope with that IMO.
paF4uko November 29th, 2008, 06:52 PM Timon, everybody from BG and RO who wanted to work abroad already did it, so you shouldn't expect waves of workers if they drop the limitations. I remember the journalists on one of London's airports on the 2-3 of January 2007, waiting for waves of workers and ultimately all they got were Chinese tourists. :)
Timon91 November 29th, 2008, 06:58 PM ^^Our politicians unfortunately don't think so. We had lots of Poles coming here in a short lapse of time, and there were some problems with housing and the conditions that some of them were living in. But because they are seasonal workers, those problems don't stay long. I look at it this way: they come here, work hard for a low wage (but high for their standards), which is good for them and for us. They give the Dutch some cheap labor, which is good for our economy, and after a while, when they've earned some money, they go back to Poland and spend it over there, supporting their economy. Looks quite much like a win-win situation IMO. Please correct me if I'm wrong.
Verso November 29th, 2008, 07:02 PM They are leaving now in the face of the recession anyway.
paF4uko November 29th, 2008, 07:08 PM ^^ No, you're absolutely right, but there are other people who are afraid of losing their jobs if someone comes in the country and work for less money which is understandable, but there's no such threat already - as I said, those who could do it, did it. :)
panda80 November 29th, 2008, 07:11 PM Timon, everybody from BG and RO who wanted to work abroad already did it, so you shouldn't expect waves of workers if they drop the limitations. I remember the journalists on one of London's airports on the 2-3 of January 2007, waiting for waves of workers and ultimately all they got were Chinese tourists. :)
u are right, all romanians that wanted to work abroad left romania some time ago, now we have 2-2.5 milion people working in spain and italy.already i think there are more coming back from these countries, as wages and need for work are continously increasing in romania, than the ones leaving romania in search for better jobs in other countries.
panda80 November 29th, 2008, 07:17 PM They are leaving now in the face of the recession anyway.
i think romania will absorb some of its people that are working now in west europe because we are not severely hit by crisis(government presume a 3 to 6% economical increase for 2009).already in spain there are 100000 romanians jobless, and many of them will for sure return home.
AUchamps November 29th, 2008, 07:33 PM They are leaving now in the face of the recession anyway.
Just like Mexicans are over here. I will say, Poles and Mexicans are the hardest working mass immigrants to come to Western Europe and the USA, respectively.
SeanT November 30th, 2008, 01:33 PM Of course. There has been taken a very big effort according to equipments and so on. Hungary has 1000s of kms to deffend as a bastion to Schengen.:cheers:
Verso November 30th, 2008, 04:02 PM Hungary has 1000s of kms to deffend as a bastion to Schengen.:cheers:
Thousands? :crazy: Exactly 1,041 km, so barely over one thousand. :D
SeanT November 30th, 2008, 05:03 PM Thousands? :crazy: Exactly 1,041 km, so barely over one thousand. :D
OKAY, then hundreds..... Now you sleep well at night..........:bash:
SeanT November 30th, 2008, 05:05 PM Thousands? :crazy: Exactly 1,041 km, so barely over one thousand. :D
Belive me, more then enough!!!!!!
Timon91 November 30th, 2008, 08:36 PM Yeah. 1041 kms is a lot to defend. Luckily with Schengen they only have the border with Croatia, Serbia, Romania and Ukraine left to defend :ohno:
Also more than enough, I'd say.
RawLee November 30th, 2008, 09:22 PM Yeah. 1041 kms is a lot to defend. Luckily with Schengen they only have the border with Croatia, Serbia, Romania and Ukraine left to defend :ohno:
Also more than enough, I'd say.
"Defend"? Maybe Check...or monitor...but defend...
Timon91 November 30th, 2008, 09:34 PM The outer EU border is quite heavily defended. But this counts especially for the Ukrainian, Russian and Belarussian borders of course. Hungary only borders to Ukraine. Croatia and Serbia might be less though....
RawLee November 30th, 2008, 09:57 PM The outer EU border is quite heavily defended. But this counts especially for the Ukrainian, Russian and Belarussian borders of course. Hungary only borders to Ukraine. Croatia and Serbia might be less though....
No,I can assure you. My gf's brother is an officer working on the ukrainen border...apart from the regular infrared-camera van and such,there are no armoured divisions stationed there...
Timon91 November 30th, 2008, 10:01 PM Ok, then I'll believe you, but there was a newspaper about a year ago (when Schengen was extended) telling about a fortified Slovakian-Ukrainian border, so I based my thoughts on that article.
RawLee November 30th, 2008, 10:10 PM Ok, then I'll believe you, but there was a newspaper about a year ago (when Schengen was extended) telling about a fortified Slovakian-Ukrainian border, so I based my thoughts on that article.
Dont believe me. Believe what you see and read!
Slartibartfas November 30th, 2008, 10:15 PM The outer EU border is quite heavily defended. But this counts especially for the Ukrainian, Russian and Belarussian borders of course. Hungary only borders to Ukraine. Croatia and Serbia might be less though....
It's not heavily defended, its heavily controlled.
Timon91 November 30th, 2008, 10:20 PM Well, you defend your border against anyone crossing it illegally, right? Or am I wrong now?
Slartibartfas November 30th, 2008, 10:34 PM Well, you defend your border against anyone crossing it illegally, right? Or am I wrong now?
The term"heavily defend" all alone is portraying it in a too militaristic way. When it is in reality just guarding the border with light equipment and surveillance tools not heavy machinery and soldiers.
Timon91 November 30th, 2008, 10:36 PM But they're patrolling and defending, right? Ok, 'heavily' is probably a bit overdone, but they do more than just controlling!
Slartibartfas November 30th, 2008, 10:38 PM But they're patrolling and defending, right? Ok, 'heavily' is probably a bit overdone, but they do more than just controlling!
What more do they do then controlling it? Patrolling is part of controlling a border. Its right though that its quite throughly controlled. Thats no wonder after all its the outer border of an economically highly developed entity with half a billion inhabitants. Thats quite an interesting incentive for for illegally crossing the border. Not just for illegal immigrants but for the organized crime as well. I would say the latter aspect is even more important.
ChrisZwolle November 30th, 2008, 10:42 PM The term"heavily defend" all alone is portraying it in a too militaristic way. When it is in reality just guarding the border with light equipment and surveillance tools not heavy machinery and soldiers.
Exactly. It's not "fortress Europe" as some like to say.
Timon91 November 30th, 2008, 10:42 PM And part of defending it.
Look, I'm not an expert in this issue. When Schengen was established I was one year old, and I've never been to the outer EU border, but in Dutch we always speak of "een grens verdedigen", so "defending a border", when translated literally. So I may be just my mistake, but my experience is that this is also called "defending" in English.
RawLee November 30th, 2008, 10:54 PM But they're patrolling and defending, right? Ok, 'heavily' is probably a bit overdone, but they do more than just controlling!
The army and the borderguards are 2 different things usually. Our border guards became police officers after joining,because the borderguards, as an institution, seized to exist. The army doesnt patrol the border. They dont have heavy guns,only pistols.
Control is indeed a soft word for what they do outside of the checkpoints. I think monitor is the best word to describe their work.
http://www.pecstv.hu/kepek/hirek/c_29216.jpg
http://www.origo.hu/i/0708/20070803autovadas.jpg
Slartibartfas November 30th, 2008, 11:08 PM And part of defending it.
Look, I'm not an expert in this issue. When Schengen was established I was one year old, and I've never been to the outer EU border, but in Dutch we always speak of "een grens verdedigen", so "defending a border", when translated literally. So I may be just my mistake, but my experience is that this is also called "defending" in English.
I am no English expert either. In German one says to control a border. I think defending is something for the army.
Wallaroo November 30th, 2008, 11:12 PM I am no English expert either. In German one says to control a border. I think defending is something for the army.Hey Slarti old chap! You seem to be everywhere on the internet...:lol:
Slartibartfas November 30th, 2008, 11:25 PM ^^ You found "my" second forum. Thats pretty much it then ;)
paF4uko December 1st, 2008, 11:30 AM Just to make it clear once again, you "defend your border" in a war, but otherwise you "control" it. Both expressions exist, but they mean different things. :)
By the way this summer I was travelling between Croatia and Slovenia without even stop the car on the border post... Every time they were just waving me to go on. Just one time I had to stop on the SLO customs post. :)
Verso December 1st, 2008, 03:21 PM ^^ That's b/c you're a Bulgarian (EU citizen). If you had Kazakh license plates, you would be stopped for sure.
SeanT December 3rd, 2008, 10:13 PM I´ve heard that there was an agreement between Slovenia/Hungary before this Schengen-affair like not using passports. Is it true???
Verso December 3rd, 2008, 11:03 PM ^^ Croats may go to Slovenia, Hungary and Italy with (valid) IDs, but they receive some kind of a paper (pasteboard), which they must keep until leaving the countries. Not terribly handy, so I'd just take my passport with me (unless I didn't have one).
SeanT December 3rd, 2008, 11:12 PM You don´t need passports in the scandinavien countries either.(you do not need to have it with you at all)....If you are danish,swedish,etc....citizen.:)
In fact you don´t even have an ID-card in DK unless you want one.
Timon91 December 3rd, 2008, 11:14 PM That's difficult. There should be rules for the entire EU, not just one or two EU-countries. But I guess that would be too difficult. Just like some EU citizens (western part) don't need special visa for the US, and other countries (some in the eastern part) do.
snupix December 3rd, 2008, 11:15 PM ^^ Croats may go to Slovenia, Hungary and Italy with (valid) IDs, but they receive some kind of a paper (pasteboard), which they must keep until leaving the countries. Not terribly handy, so I'd just take my passport with me (unless I didn't have one).
Yeah, but if you are a frequent traveller and need to save space in the passport, it is useful. But it was better before 2007, without these papers.
Well, at least we can go to Bosnia with the ID card only :)
Verso December 12th, 2008, 12:00 AM Is Switzerland already in Schengen?
Verso December 12th, 2008, 12:16 AM Apparently the border with Liechtenstein won't be directly controlled, just with cameras 24/7:Einen Spezialfall stellt für eine Übergangszeit die Grenze zu Liechtenstein dar, weil das Fürstentum erst nach der Schweiz assoziiertes Schengen-Mitglied wird. Vereinbart worden sind eine 24-Stunden-Videoüberwachung an den befahrbaren Grenzübergängen, gemeinsame Sicherheitsanalysen des GWK und der Polizeikorps St. Gallens, Graubündens und Liechtensteins, mobile Kontrollen des GWK im Grenzraum und eine Aufwertung des Verbindungsbüros in Schaanwald (GWK, Polizeien Liechtensteins und Österreichs) zur Zentrale für die Koordinierung der sicherheits- und grenzpolizeilichen Massnahmen.I'm not sure what's with the Liechtenstein-Austrian border.
Timon91 December 12th, 2008, 08:25 AM It's the 12th now, so it should be. The Dutch tv text service and a very good news site www.nu.nl haven't yet mentioned it though :dunno:
DanMs December 12th, 2008, 09:19 AM I can see W.Europe suffering from financial crisis. "Christmass gift" or "come spend here"
Dan December 12th, 2008, 10:18 AM On the news here they're talking the 'barriers' being lifted.
I hope it stays this way and that it doesn't revert back next year...
PLH December 12th, 2008, 11:24 AM I hope it stays this way and that it doesn't revert back next year...
Sure, why would it change?
Dan December 12th, 2008, 12:25 PM If they vote no to allowing Romanians and Bulgarians free movement, the borders come back up. The EU won't let them be part of Schengen then.
ABRob December 12th, 2008, 05:52 PM Is Switzerland already in Schengen?Yes they are now.
But there are still border controls, because CH is not part of the single European market.
Timon91 December 12th, 2008, 06:34 PM ^^But only for trucks, right?
ABRob December 12th, 2008, 06:50 PM No.
Schengen means, that the customs officer aren't asking for your passport anymore, but they continue to ask, if you have dutiable goods with you.
Timon91 December 12th, 2008, 06:56 PM In that case it doesn't really make sense to me anymore. The same way on the airport. Tickets are sold by name, so you have to show your id that the ticket belongs to you, even when you fly in the Schengen area.
Verso December 12th, 2008, 07:42 PM ^^ Yeah, but they won't go investigating, if you're some kind of a criminal at airports. It's the same on the Norwegian border.
Yes they are now.I meant at midnight. ;) And yes, they entered at midnight.
|
|