Who Is The Most Successful President Egypt Had?

[xAbd0o]

Vote and discuss. don't get the debate go too hot.

what you waiting for Let Start.

[reda85]

Mubarak 1988-9999

[future_architect96]

:

[egypt69]

Each of them really have major flaws. Nasser's economic policies were really bad, Sadat discriminated against Copts, and Mubarak, ofcourse, for obvious reasons, I dont even have to explain why he's horrible.

But if I had to choose one, it would be Sadat because he achieved a significant military victory by crossing the Suez, & made peace with Isreal, which was a good move for our country and the region.

[xAbd0o]

LOL was nice joke wasn't it? haha.


I voted El Sadat. because he did handle it right and he wasn't scared from anyone he came after the war and he is the reason why Egypt have infrastructure and good economy.

[future_architect96]

i picked Gamal Abdel Nasser i think that he's better. i don't agree with some of the choices Anwar El Sadat made

[xAbd0o]

why? why do you think Gamal abdel naser is better? I think he wasn't free he was under control of corruption. unlike el sadat he put all people on power the 5% in nowadays he put them in jail because he know that they control him and cause corruption but he wanted to fix Egypt after the war.

[future_architect96]

all four of them had flaws i didn't pick anwar sadat because i think he made bad choices during his presidency like making peace with Isreal and the other two were bad presidents to so i picked Gamal abdel naser

[MASRI]

Originally Posted by future_architect96

all four of them had flaws i didn't pick anwar sadat because i think he made bad choices during his presidency like making peace with Isreal and the other two were bad presidents to so i picked Gamal abdel naser

Peace with Israel is among the main reasons Egypt is in a relative state of political stability. Wars would have done nothing good to Egypt, only more desruction and an economy that is heavily in debt.

As for the actual poll...

Mohamed Naguib was used by the Free Officers as their "head" since he was pretty old and had alot of influence. But after taking over the country, he was used as a puppet, and was thrown out, dare I say, illegally by a bunch of corrupt soldiers.

Gamal Abdel Nasser on the other hand lead Egypt into a state of patriotism and nationalism. Egypt was pretty much involved in every single war in the region: Israel (48, 67), Yemen, and Algeria. He, along with the Free Officers are among the people responsible for everything post-revolution. Education, economy, and every single industry in Egypt faultered under their control.

Anwar ElSadat ... the man who wanted to bring democracy to Egypt. He knew it would not be implemented until peace with achieved with Israel and the Arabs. A future where Egyptians can live in a country without bloodshed. He had planned to step down from the presidency after the complete return of Sinai. He did throw alot of people in jail during the time he wanted to accomplish and sign the peace treaty, because he saw certain people as a barrier to his peace intiative. Those people included both Muslims and Coptics. He never solely stood against Coptics.

Hosni Mubarak ... Our best president ever, in my opinion. He has his issues, and they are big, but I really respect what HE was able to do for Egypt through the past 30 years or so. I won't get into details on the good, and the bad he did, cause I've discussed those like 10 times.

[Ikengawo]

from what little i know about egyptian history, Nasser.
hell of a builder and leader with vision

[xAbd0o]

Originally Posted by Ikengawo

from what little i know about egyptian history, Nasser.
hell of a builder and leader with vision

where did you hear that? he did the worst things you can imagine to Egyptian Rights and Human Rights.

less than a week before I was watching a program on TV an Interview with a famous Egyptian actor and she didn't recover until today of what he done to her and many other Egyptians.

[MASRI]

Originally Posted by Ikengawo

from what little i know about egyptian history, Nasser.
hell of a builder and leader with vision

I think thats what Nasser lacked most...a true vision for Egypt's future.

[future_architect96]

i think peace with israel was a bad move we could have finished israel and restored peace to Palestine look at what their doing in Gaza. children are being killed .we could have put a stop to that but we didn't

[Ikengawo]

why do muslims sympathize with palestine SO much, but muslim children are being killed elsewhere in great numbers and its not as big a deal?

[future_architect96]

Originally Posted by Ikengawo

why do muslims sympathize with palestine SO much, but muslim children are being killed elsewhere in great numbers and its not as big a deal?

where elsewhere

[egypt69]

Stay on topic guys.

[xAbd0o]

what you talking about we where just in war with them our military and equipments where almost vanished. we requested help from every single Arab country for another war to finish it off and all of them refused and stood against us the only thing could be done is just making peace with Israel.

we where under pressure our self we should think about ourselves and our problems and solve them before solving others. if he didn't do that Egypt will be just an expand to what is happening in Palestine now. just like south Lebanon.

[future_architect96]

Originally Posted by xAbd0o

what you talking about we where just in war with them our military and equipments where almost vanished. we requested help from every single Arab country for another war to finish it off and all of them refused and stood against us the only thing could be done is just making peace with Israel.

we where under pressure our self we should think about ourselves and our problems and solve them before solving others. if he didn't do that Egypt will be just an expand to what is happening in Palestine now. just like south Lebanon.

i'm just saying we should have finished what we started

[egypt69]

Stay on topic please, none of this Israel/Palestine stuff, otherwise thread will be locked.

[MASRI]

I think I'm the only one who voted for Mubarak so far. lol Come on, I need some support here.