it’s quite a meh design. Wish we have a design comp too like Sydney for every mid to large scale development
Developer to turn Rich Lister’s CBD site into $420m hotel towerIs there a thread for this ? Developer to turn Rich Lister’s CBD site into $420m hotel tower
View attachment 5178784![]()
Developer to turn Rich Lister’s CBD site into $420m hotel tower
The site at the western end of Collins Street opposite Southern Cross Station has been co-owned by pokies king Bruce Mathieson for decades.www.afr.com
certainly a shitload better than what it's replaced. Yes it's stumpy and a tad generic - we know it's proximity to the Yarra informs much of this.I think it looks great....
....will be written on Melbourne's grave...certainly a shitload better than what it's replaced.
LOOKS GOOD TO ME. DEPENDS ON FINAL DETAILING, FINISH AND MATERIALS. BULK IS FINE FOR THAT SITE. WISH THE PROJECT HAD INCLUDED THE DEMO-ING OF THAT POS PEBBLECRETE MONSTER NEXT DOOR ON COLLINS
Agree… looks clean, sleek and modern!Looks Great from my perspective!
Really, Positive Pete? 🥳....will be written on Melbourne's grave...
When exactly did Melbourne have a reputation for good urban design and mojo? I’m not saying this to be critical, I think the lack of architectural consistency and the somewhat eclectic nature of our skyline provides a unique and interesting character. Those factors also mean that perceptions of the city are probably more resilient. The addition of yet another tower with questionable architectural merit in Melbourne just adds to the kaleidoscope, whereas a sub-par outcome in a city with a bit more consistency in its urban design like Sydney can easily end up being perceived as an eyesore. Just look at the lukewarm response to salesforce.LOL - fair enough. Believe me...I would LOVE for something to be announced on this forum that I could finally comment positively on. I've been on here for as long as I can even remember (I think it was around the time of the announcement of the redevelopment of Spencer Street Station!!)
I've mostly loved it, but these days there's not alot of crow about in Melbourne.. I understand times have been tough recently, but I also honestly think this city has lost its urban design and architectural Mojo......for whatever reason.
Fingers crossed for STH BNK....
Totally agree for the city urban environment.... the cheap native gum tree/shrubs, scrappy yellow grasses & gravel (eg: Flinders st & much of Docklands) seems to be the 'go-to' for this MCC. Such a shame when you look at all the beautiful gardens previously created when we were once known as the 'Garden State'.... ('IMO' - before I get attacked for sharing my view).^^^
The street level urban design in Melbourne is sub-par. It wasn't in the early 1990s through to the early 2002s but it has of recent time been lacklustre, I'm sure with the decline of the street level design will come a change and push and we will see a renaissance of sorts soon, but at the moment lots of the street level amenity is cold, stark, and somewhat lacking in long term consistency and vision, I did say some, not all, but I think that may be what Garmatt is referring to.