SkyscraperCity banner
1 - 9 of 9 Posts

·
Moderator
Joined
·
122,256 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
High-rise will block air flow, Jardine's Lookout residents say
19 July 2009
South China Morning Post

Residents of a private estate in Jardine's Lookout staged a protest yesterday, saying a high-rise being erected by New World Development will encroach on their private space and block the flow of air.

About 10 representatives of the 80 households in Dragon Garden, Chun Fai Terrace, hoisted banners and chanted slogans outside the Villa Splendor construction site.

They complained that an outside wall of the planned 40-storey residential building comes so close to Dragon Garden's car park that it leaves no space for air to flow.

Meanwhile, temporary panels set up around the construction site have blocked almost one-third of a four-metre-wide access road that belongs to Dragon Garden.

Over the past few months, heavy trucks carrying construction materials have damaged the road surface and threatened the safety of pedestrians when they back up on the narrow roadway, they said.

"Neither the developer nor the construction company have consulted our opinions about these issues, which have seriously infringed on our rights," said Tan Kai-nin, 52, a member of the Dragon Garden property owners' committee.

Residents say they are fed up with the government's lack of help and pass-the-buck response to their many complaints to the Buildings Department, Lands Department and other government departments over the past two years.

"We thought about taking it to court, but that would be very costly. To come out and fight for our interests is the only thing we can do now," Mr Tan said.

Eastern District councillor Tsang Kin-shing showed his support by joining the protesters yesterday. Pointing to the unfinished concrete pillars built right next to the estate's car park, he said: "This is totally irresponsible; it will block the air flow into the car park. We urge [New World] to have a meeting with the residents to settle the problems."

Another resident, a Mr Tsui, said the market price of their flats had stalled at about HK$7,000 per square foot since the building work began, while the price for other estate blocks of similar quality in the area had climbed to about HK$10,000.

A New World spokesman said the company would look into the matter and follow up on complaints.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,086 Posts
I fail to see how one building can make a 'wall effect'. The term is being abused these days.
I know! It's ridiculous.

I'm no aerodynamic engineer, but common sense dictates that air flow is far more affected when 15 towers of 50 storeys are lined up next to each other, than when one single slim 80 storey tower is erected.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,202 Posts
I know! It's ridiculous.

I'm no aerodynamic engineer, but common sense dictates that air flow is far more affected when 15 towers of 50 storeys are lined up next to each other, than when one single slim 80 storey tower is erected.
That's exactly why I think height limits could actually worsen instead of mitigating the problem!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,086 Posts
That's exactly why I think height limits could actually worsen instead of mitigating the problem!
Good point - property developers are far more likely to build several shorter stubby towers instead of one tall one.

Incidentally, were The Cullinan Towers not supposed to be one? But they decided to split it into two (obviously the height of the one tower wasn't going to be the addition of the two).
 

·
Industrial Twilight
Joined
·
1,097 Posts
If it really did block the flow of air, why is that so bad anyways? Since the air quality sucks as it is...

(kidding) :lol:

But yeah, I think they just want to keep the view.
If you posted pics or renders I can't seem to see them either.
 

·
Moderator
Joined
·
16,917 Posts
Updates?
 
1 - 9 of 9 Posts
Top