Joined
·
7,910 Posts
Not really. That is the way of development of any established city in the world, barring few cities of China. And for Services industry, social infrastructure is 100 times more important than physical infra. If not, NYC would have lost the tag to another US city long back. Roads in NYC is no match to those in other cities. And a Bangalore still cannot be IT capital of India.I think we all would agree on the fact that Mumbai is way over it's capcity and doesn't have the capability of upgrading it's infrastructure to modern standards anytime soon (next 5-10 years), buying old areas, selling them to builders, notifications to residents and we all know how long the drama would go on for. No doubt Mumbai would remain a financial hub and a lot more relevant than GIFT. But GIFT can be built with modern infrastructure, a well connected city that can monitor and respond to emergencies and health of it's citizens and so on. Things that Mumbai or any other major city can't even dream of. Let's be realistic here, old cities like Mumbai simply don't have the capacity to renovate themselves, not atleast without a committed local govt. or a communist bulldozer party than can flatten everything that comes in it's path and build a brand new infra in it's place. GIFT provides an opportunity for investors to invest their money in, something that is required, we need investment to grow and prosper and to build low developed cities. So, talking down on GIFT is stupid because it may not be able to rival bigger cities, it sure is comparable to our rivals (China,US) infrastructure. It is a good model for our politicians and planners to follow. It is a next step for our cities.
And to be frank, SSC has an an obsession for roads and nothing else. Mumbai still has one of the best infrastructure in India with ample water, power, reasonable public transporation, completely underground utilities. There are 2 aspects, it has to correct - housing for low income group and modern public transportation. In both counts, there is a gradual improvement. We wish it is faster , but that is how things move in most of India. The ultimate asset of Mumbai is its corporate friendly culture (specifically service industries).
ps: I am not comparing Mumbai with GIFT. But there is no need to downgrade Mumbai to praise GIFT either. And there is only one financial hub/capital per country in any country in the world. And that is how finance industry works.