Skyscraper City Forum banner
1 - 20 of 27 Posts

·
I claim to be staff.
Joined
·
2,171 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·


2007 proposal from Fürer + gas-trust architecture. Their main office is in Gossau, Switzerland and they have a subsidiary office in Milwaukee.

I don't really know anything about this proposal but I do know this - it's awesome.
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
662 Posts
JEEE-SUS.

That building looks impressively tall. I counted about 46 stories, but that was quick count. I don't care for the design, or the fact that it's in the 3rd ward but after 30+ years with the same tallest building I think it's time a new one gets built. Although I doubt this one will.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,089 Posts
Our new tallest shouldn't be that particular building. I just don't see all the hype and fanfare this building gets.

I remember some posters complaining about the Moderne looking like UCT/KT combined. Doesn't the white/grey/black parts of this building look like Ruvin's proposal?

Cheesy.
 

·
I claim to be staff.
Joined
·
2,171 Posts
Discussion Starter · #4 ·
Our new tallest shouldn't be that particular building. I just don't see all the hype and fanfare this building gets.

I remember some posters complaining about the Moderne looking like UCT/KT combined. Doesn't the white/grey/black parts of this building look like Ruvin's proposal?

Cheesy.
Well brewcity, it looks like you just owned yourself.

Honestly I think ever since the Calatrava addition we Milwaukeeians have always expected ultra-super-top notch proposals. It's like nothing (and I mean NOTHING) is ever to our appeasement. Every proposal within the past month (I could probably say the past 4 months) that has shown its lovely facade on our forum has been bashed, ridiculed, and torn apart to nothingness. It's honestly getting a bit annoying.
 

·
muted
Joined
·
7,080 Posts
How can this one be the potential tallest in the city? US Bank Center may be only 42 stories, but it's a 600 footer. This one doesn't look like it will be that tall. Nonetheless, I love the design. It will be located at Water and what other street?
 

·
1981 Civic
Joined
·
2,911 Posts
Damn, that bad boy is nice. I hope this one gets built. There's nothing worse than seeing otherwise excellent proposals self-destruct in your face time and time again.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
531 Posts
Here's my humble two cents worth. From the rendering it looks like three separate buildings quished together. The "far left" side reminds me of a much shorter version of the John Hancock Tower in Chicago, only with light blue tinted glass instead of the JHT's darker tint. Specifically, the prominent X-bracing as shown in the rendering. The "middle" portion looks like a taller design of Ruvin's proposal as others have stated. And the "far right" side looks like a building that was plucked from another spot in the 3rd Ward and they stuck it right there. My preference would be to use the "far left" design as the overall design for the whole building.

I like the height, of course, duh! But I tend to agree with those that believe this would be better if it was located in a more centralized location of the CBD.

If this rendering illustrates a semi-serious proposal from a European corporation for their Milwaukee/USA headquarters as MM is alluding to, it might stand a better than zero chane of becoming a reality some day. At least it would seem less speculative than other proposals such as LPT or Ghazi's.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,089 Posts
Well brewcity, it looks like you just owned yourself.
Yes and no, Mark.

This has probably been maybe the 3rd building I've stood to say i don't like. My record for building approvals would be amazing compared to the likes of yourself and a few others.

Milwaukee posters DO over-do it, mostly for the smallest reasons - and then (as we see here) they become complete hypocrits of themselves...... (let's not have a look-a-like building but then support a look-a-like building.... :nuts: )

When i don't like something, there's generally a reason and I stick to it (Kimpton design I hate, this design I hate, etc, etc)....

I hope that makes sense.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,384 Posts
And the "far right" side looks like a building that was plucked from another spot in the 3rd Ward and they stuck it right there. My preference would be to use the "far left" design as the overall design for the whole building.
Actually, the far right building was stuck right there several decades ago. It's the existing building next door to what would be the new building (far left and middle) that is envisioned for the adjacent surface parking lot on the southwest corner of N. Water Street and E. St. Paul Avenue.

If this rendering illustrates a semi-serious proposal from a European corporation for their Milwaukee/USA headquarters as MM is alluding to, it might stand a better than zero chane of becoming a reality some day. At least it would seem less speculative than other proposals such as LPT or Ghazi's.
There is some confusion here. MilwMark was referring to the architects who designed the building...not any possible corporate tenants/headquarters for the building. The architects have two firms: one in Gossau, Switzerland (Fürer + Gastrau Architektur), and one in Milwaukee (Gastrau Fuerer & Associates...which coincidentally has its offices in part of that historic building on the far right in the rendering).
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
531 Posts
Markitect, thanks for clearing up my confusion. Well then, the rendering is just another architecture firm's speculative trial balloon for Milwaukee. I suspect that these firms throw out these design exercises to the public (Like throwing raw meat to the wolves on this website!) to solicit positive feed-back to lure developers.
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
499 Posts
For me, if the design was primarily patterned after the "left-side" and located in the CBD, I think it would be an awesome addition to Milwaukee's skyline.
Yep. Agreed...like on the block east of the Pfister. There is currently a parking lot on the north side of the block, and if this - or something similar in height - was built there, it would really fill in a key space in the skyline. In fact, wasn't somebody floating an idea for a building at that location a few years back?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
749 Posts
Yep. Agreed...like on the block east of the Pfister. There is currently a parking lot on the north side of the block, and if this - or something similar in height - was built there, it would really fill in a key space in the skyline. In fact, wasn't somebody floating an idea for a building at that location a few years back?
I think there were discussions, but no formal plans. This would be good for the Milwaukee Athletic Club parking structure on Milwaukee and Wells Street. They were officially looking for developers a year or two ago.
 

·
born again cyclist
Joined
·
3,671 Posts
whoops, i didn't know this one had its own thread already...........

i love, LOVE, LOVE this design. if only i had a couple hundred million just laying around to foolishly throw at this proejct to make it a reality.

must. build. now.

too bad it's probably just a vision with a snowball's chance in hell of getting off the drawing boards.
 

·
urban informant
Joined
·
669 Posts
How close is this to 794 if it is pretty close and the LPT is built is think that would look very cool. If some other high rises were built too near this propsed one. Or just some infill around this one I think it would give our skyline a really cool effect looking from the east or west.....
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
217 Posts
My 2 cents worth says, At least it looks a hell of a lot better than the 700 foot mueseum tower proposed for Louisville KY. And if nothing else, if this tower doesnt get built, at least there is some intrest in building a new tallest for Milwaukee.
 
1 - 20 of 27 Posts
Top