SkyscraperCity Forum banner

Questions

928 Views 4 Replies 5 Participants Last post by  Beiruti
So I just read this article (Title: "Hezbollah says its arms needed to resist Israel") and I had some questions. First, I want to apologize for posting something that is perhaps political nature (given that I can't post in EAYOR), but it got me wondering.

1) If Israel withdraws from Ghajjar and hands over this village to Lebanon, then wouldn't this diminish the validity of Hizbullah's argument that resistance is necessary in order to regain "Lebanese territory occupied by Israel"? I mean, Israel will have now withdrawn, under relatively peaceful circumstances, from three different occupied territories- Sinai, Gaza, and now Ghajjar, without any need for "resistance" from the Egyptians, Gazans or Ghajjaris.

2) Ghajjar and the Shebaa Farms were originally captured from Syria (the residents of the village possess Syrian national ID cards, but not Lebanese ID cards). Also, according to the article, "Israel seized Chebaa Farms and Kfar Chouba Hills from Syria in the 1967 Mideast war. Lebanon and Syria claim it is Lebanese territory. But a U.N.-drawn border between Israel and Lebanon marks it as Syrian land under Israeli occupation." If it is Syrian territory, then why should it be "returned" to Lebanon, when it was never Lebanese to begin with?

3) Once Israel hands back the Shebaa Farms to either Syria or Lebanon (I think this is inevitable), will Hizbullah disarm, since its weapons are meant for "resisting" Israeli occupation (but surprisingly not Syrian occupation) of Lebanese lands?
See less See more
Status
Not open for further replies.
1 - 5 of 5 Posts
^^ Lots of wrong info. included.

and seriously,no need to discus these points,but if u want an answer,

If israel withdraws from northern ghajar ( people built on it after occupation of south lebanon ) and Shebaa farms who's Lebanese as per the 1923 map that put northern ghajar inside Lebanon,then hizbullah will be under huge pressure from most of the Lebanese to disarm and integrate within the Lebanese army.
See less See more
Hassoun the only pressure will come from Iran and Syria. The Lebanese have no say in the matter! Hisballa's followers will back them up no matter what. If Israel did withndraw from all occupied lands nothing will be achieved, they will come up with another excuse like liberating Palestinian Lands.
See less See more
HAHA

It is quite funny how a moderator has not closed the thread yet. If a thread that was 1/100000 political as this one but was against Israel, it would be closed within seconds. Chevre's post is a explicitly breaking the rules. Whatever though, its not worth the waja ras
חבר1.0 - there is a reason why you cant post in EAYOR. It being closed does not mean it's OK to post EAYOR topics elsewhere.

:lock:
1 - 5 of 5 Posts
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top